credit card processing regulations canada call home depot credit card services 0 fee credit card transfer balance how to get free credit card numbers that work credit cards that give you cashback on gas ge money bank discount tire credit card credit card advice blog american express premier rewards gold card review jcpenney credit card phone number compare credit card processing machines natwest credit card minimum payment percentage mbna credit card reviews canada wells fargo lowest credit card rate uk credit cards capital one application for credit card td visa card activation number buy virtual credit card india 5000 no credit check credit card cibc aventura credit card travel insurance activity 1 choosing a credit card worksheet credit card for business with no personal guarantee visa credit card fees for businesses td cash back visa card go ge capital retail bank credit cards navy federal credit union jacksonville fl 10 best credit card processing companies sbi credit card statement request bp gas company credit cards value city credit card approval short term bad credit loans uk virtual visa cards india anz platinum credit card buy online visa gift card with paypal credit card limit reduced no notification first premier bank credit card bill pay mastercard securecode yorkshire bank best credit cards for very poor credit good credit cards to apply for to build credit mophie iphone credit card reader cancel chase southwest credit card barclays platinum credit card india payday loans uk reviews tesco credit card credit balance orchard unsecured credit card for bad credit declined for capital one secured credit card uk how to get a credit card with no credit and no deposit how to pay cibc credit card bill online alaska airlines business credit card phone number federal credit card protection act er diagram for credit card fraud detection system wireless credit card machines for iphone best student visa cards canada alaska airlines preferred visa secured credit card unsecured credit cards to help rebuild credit credit card information form pdf credit card fraud detection project best unsecured credit cards to build credit online payday loans instant approval direct lenders no credit check where to buy prepaid visa credit cards nab platinum credit cards travel insurance how to get rid of credit card debt uk best credit card for travel rewards canada 2013 eliminate credit card debt calculator best value travel rewards credit card secured guaranteed credit card canada tips on how to prevent credit card fraud debt settlement letter to credit card company bank of america unsecured credit card for bad credit citibank business credit card sign in instant payday loans uk pay capital one credit card online prepaid credit cards online betting first usa credit card master trust easy payday loans uk no credit check credit card special offers canada scan pc for credit card numbers how much to offer credit card settlement cleartrip hdfc credit card offer capital one credit card with bad credit best credit cards for rewards canada small bad credit loans instant decision balance transfer credit cards no fee chase credit card history next payday advance email capital one prepaid visa credit cards canadian tire mastercard bill payment prepaid mastercard gift card pay hdfc master credit card how to get a business loan with bad credit to start business sparkly gold cardigan credit card fraud uk 2012 credit cards poor credit uk jcpenney credit card payment number icici bank credit cards customer care number santander credit card instant decision best travel reward credit card 2013 chase credit card application phone number cash back cards singapore rbc visa cards business compare credit cards canada air miles chase credit card loan consolidation fee free credit cards visa credit card with no annual fees personal online loans is discover credit card good calls about lowering credit card interest rates best buy rewards credit cards payment list of department store credit cards are capital one secured credit cards good gemb jcpenney credit card phone number secured credit cards canada visa 100 guaranteed credit card compare the market student credit cards united cash loans scams credit card companies that help rebuild credit what credit cards can i apply for first credit card history natwest credit card balance transfer fee ways to prevent credit card fraud online walmart credit card review new business credit cards with no credit history credit card application no credit check cibc 1 cash back visa application for orchard bank secured credit card debit visa card td visa credit card for businesses top secured credit cards with no annual fee cost of mobile credit card terminal first premier credit card 700 limit portable credit card terminal rental what is the best credit card to have for students experian credit score easy credit card to apply for in canada types of credit cards visa mastercard kwik pay direct loans student credit cards uk how do i get a portable credit card machine for my business balance transfer credit cards wikipedia easy payday loans online no faxing square credit card reader hidden fees student visa canada credit card orchard bank credit card application page bpi application for credit card military pay advances credit card authorization form australian embassy credit card services natwest online are us bank credit cards hard to get best credit card for bad credit history citibank credit card online payment us can get discover credit card bad credit short term personal loan bad credit what is a good credit card apr 2013 5 cash back gasoline credit card major credit cards accepted in jamaica cibc credit card application status mobile credit card processing iphone reviews natwest credit card 0 22 months easiest credit card to get with no credit 2011 pay capital 1 credit card online chase credit card student visa easy application for credit cards philippines marathon gas credit card offer how to get a cash advance on a bank of america credit card how do i enter credit card processing fees in quickbooks how to cancel a best buy credit card top credit cards for students canada online cash advance payday loans in canada anz credit card charges overseas visa credit card security number now on sale at starbucks square credit card reader ba visa credit card uk top 10 credit card issuers united states rbs credit card payment protection accept credit cards uk how to use td canada trust visa debit 0 interest credit card offers on balance transfers accept credit cards online free canadian tire options credit card login payday loans cash advance - apply online discountadvances.com how long does a capital one balance transfer take sears credit cards login mastercard usaa credit card phone number free credit card numbers and security code 2012 easy credit card checker download free travel credit card holder credit cards with travel rewards for students lufthansa miles and more credit card review apply credit card with bad credit history philippines 24 month interest free credit card track citibank credit card application status online india best balance transfer offers use of company credit card policy hsbc gold credit card benefits best reward credit card singapore citibank malaysia credit card application form how to use a credit card to build good credit credit card debt settlement malaysia credit card abroad best 0 percent balance transfer credit card walmart credit card reviews 2011 visa credit card verification india discover credit card visa mastercard prepaid no fee credit card credit cards for bad credit no deposit no processing fee tier points for gold card ba best first credit card 2013 credit cards for small business owners with no credit citi credit cards rewards login top premium credit cards in india check visa gift card balance online free obituary search no credit card how to make instant payments with paypal without a credit card bad credit credit cards canada no deposit how to pay hdfc credit card bill online from icici bank 12 month bad credit loans uk chase freedom credit card logon online application for credit card of hdfc bank disney credit card login chase credit card services online payment bp chase disney credit card rewards chase credit cards with chip and pin in usa american express credit card credit score the best credit cards for college students 2012 get a credit card online with bad credit buy virtual credit card online instant online payday loan lenders uk portable credit card machines canada td canada trust visa rewards free credit cards hdfc credit card apply contact number need a personal loan with bad credit fast halifax credit card ppi calculator how do i apply for best buy credit card credit card with no credit check who has the best credit card rewards program best payday loans like wonga free credit card validator online canara bank global credit card application form pdf credit card validator app for android capital one secured credit card review credit card for college students in india cheap credit card machines uk apply for lloyds tsb student credit card student credit cards with no credit required compare low interest credit cards first horizon credit card services canada credit card capital one unsecured credit cards for bad credit what is a credit card that offers a 0 transfer balance what is a cvv security code on a credit card rbs credit card balance transfer deals kindle amazon credit card deal gas station credit cards canada citibank credit card loans philippines shell gas credit card online application credit card visa application instant cash loans online australia credit card comparisons credit card debt written off on death apply for business credit card best credit cards no interest balance transfer the source by circuit city credit card can you get cash advance credit card mobile credit card processing android best credit card bad credit halifax credit card application update guaranteed secured credit card for bad credit easy credit cards to get with bad credit 2013 low interest credit cards uk credit cards for fair credit rating uk credit card credit balance cash til payday loans in georgia best miles credit card offers 2013 pay credit card student loan halifax reward credit card ?5 online application for sbi railway credit card credit card with 0 balance transfer fee sbi credit card online verification citi-shell credit card phone number bad credit loan uk reviews home depot canada credit card address guaranteed instant approval unsecured credit card cash advance loans online australia all credit cards in one app easy payday loans no credit check household income credit card application parents credit card interest rate calculator canada anz gold card travel insurance how to buy a house with bad credit and no money down 2013 javascript credit card number validator online visa card balance check standard chartered credit card loan interest rate 0 interest credit card explained post bankruptcy credit cards unsecured hsbc premier credit card rewards uk railway sbi platinum card walgreens prepaid credit cards second mortgages for bad credit 18 month 0 interest credit cards comparison between credit cards in malaysia canada trust credit card interest kohls credit card bill pay store reward cards credit card fees for small businesses kohls credit card application online i need a short term bad credit loan no credit bad credit car loans hdfc credit card statement through sms dispute letter to credit card company visa card security code generator online top credit card companies for college students how to build credit fast without a credit card commonwealth gold credit card travel insurance canadian tire credit card rewards visa black card requirements review orchard bank credit card customer login best free credit cards rewards free credit card app for windows phone cash rewards gas credit cards premier first credit card unsecured credit cards bad credit no annual fee accept credit cards with paypal mobile asking for credit card rate reduction alternative to paypal credit card processing what does a nandos black card do the best prepaid credit cards in canada hdfc titanium international visa credit card dubai first credit card golf credit card swipe fees explained first premier credit card status credit card credit rating india credit card limits calculated how much is a walmart prepaid credit card cash reward credit cards compare credit card verification form credit card consolidation king;s gta v pnc secured credit card limit black card benefits amex gas rewards credit card canada real payday loan lenders online barclay credit card payment india credit card payments through ebay best credit cards with low interest 12 month bad credit loan lenders rbs credit card services southend on sea uk credit card interest free period credit card interest free periods explained tesco visa card online banking how do i cancel my virgin credit card platinum card requirements malaysia disney credit card perks direct cash advance lenders no fax apply for credit card with bad credit no annual fee do i need a credit card for itunes capital one secured credit card usa best credit card to rebuild bad credit 2012 visa credit card application for usa tesco clubcard credit card 0 ladies black cardigan how to get a loan with bad credit history uk capital 1 credit card online manhattan standard chartered credit card payment online hsbc student credit card charges how to apply for a credit card santander valid credit card numbers that work 2013 visa hsbc business credit card bad credit cash loans with bad credit australia government help with credit card debt 2011 ebay credit card wallet hdfc bank credit card login registration top cash back rewards credit cards unsecured credit cards for rebuilding bad credit chase credit card services amazon unsecured major credit cards for bad credit free credit card numbers that work online credit card debt consolidation programs bank of america credit card fraud protection credit card score estimator discover credit card approval process visa virtual credit card canada sign up for credit card with no credit check credit card for college students with no credit history apply for credit card canada visa legacy visa credit card application status hdfc bank credit card payment options apply for walmart credit card over the phone how to calculate monthly credit card interest payments can i get a credit card with bad credit and no deposit need to get a credit card quickly cash back credit cards uk 2013 how can i apply for visa credit card halifax credit card ppi claim success ipad without credit card apps best credit card deals 2012 credit card app for cell phone best premium travel credit cards the best credit cards to have in usa unsecured credit card for bad credit with no deposit credit card debt mortgage refinance new tesco credit card payment details best buy reward zone mastercard review pc financial credit card contact number best credit card reward offers 2012 mbna canada credit card offers capitec debt consolidation loan online application wells fargo credit card rate reduction no interest credit cards on purchases citibank customer care credit card scotiabank student visa credit card dandy cash payday loans change ebay credit card details compare air miles credit cards uk easy credit card for bad credit best credit card reward programs consumer report how long does it take to get credit card from credit one icici master credit card offers visa credit card cash withdrawal fees buy facebook credits gift cards online credit cards for students with poor credit history using your credit cards in canada best buy credit card application denied online loans today uk capital one secured visa credit card reviews credit card for business travel bad credit how to apply for credit card hsbc what happens to credit card debt when you die in texas best reward credit cards 2013 uk how to get out of a joint credit card account can best buy credit cards be used anywhere fast cash loans liverpool prepaid credit card paypal recharge guarenteed payday loan no credit check uk cimb credit card visa signature bank of america credit card uk amazon low credit credit cards applications check status of belk credit card application how does opening new credit cards affect credit score add halifax credit card online banking balance transfer cards go compare credit cards uk lowest apr credit card offers standard chartered credit card reward points catalogue pakistan cheapest virtual credit card terminal ebay paypal without credit card lost walmart credit card number check hdfc credit card payment status new credit cards 2013 us bank credit card rates credit cards that offer cashback on gas purchases capital one credit card instant decision citibank credit card rewards indonesia barclays credit card login dubai what credit cards are in the mbna group can you make credit card payments with paypal low interest credit cards nz bank of america secured credit card status credit card style business cards best rewards credit cards bank of america rbs student credit card declined lic of india premium payment by credit cards credit card routing number location instant approval credit card offers in india easiest credit card to get with bad credit chase circuit city credit card best buy payday bad credit loans online bank of america credit card customer service phone number best post bankruptcy credit cards portable wireless credit card machine prepaid international credit card ez payday advance lawrence ks how often can you apply for citi credit cards best credit card offer malaysia prepaid credit cards visa uk credit cards that earn miles with no annual fee discover credit card 0 balance transfer fee wells fargo credit card travel points credit card consolidation non profit organization online visa card payment chase credit cards online bill payment balance transfer credit cards for bad credit bank of america virtual credit card prepaid us credit cards for foreigners american aadvantage credit card 50000 miles apply for credit card credit union do i need a credit card for paypal yahoo cash advance reviews online alaska airlines credit card canada companion ticket does walmart accept visa debit cards capital one credit cards are they good british airways credit card deal hsbc credit card term loan bad credit credit cards unsecured no deposit how does a credit card work online dbs debit visa card activation credit card app iphone singapore credit cards comparison 2012 sear credit card rewards program apply platinum credit card hdfc bank citibank business credit card phone number sears citibank credit card login in hsbc online credit card application form american airlines credit card offers 50000 miles how do amscot payday advances work best instant approval credit cards 2012 bank of america credit cards customer service phone number chase credit card price protection when will i receive my first premier credit card credit limit calculator uk credit card payment protection plan apply online for credit card hdfc instant online cash advance australia best 0 credit card offers 2013 most popular credit cards in the world credit card settlement letter sample best rate credit cards australia citibank credit card offers mumbai apple credit card swiper uk can i use my cibc visa debit card online chase toys r us credit card customer service number guaranteed car finance bad credit best rewards credit card with lowest interest rate best direct payday loan lenders fast cash advance online loans can i use my old navy visa card anywhere ge capital credit card payment does chase bank offer payday advances business credit cards with rewards no annual fee td ameritrade visa debit card walmart credit card score iphone credit card reader lowest rate best buy credit card vs reward zone mastercard can i use my citi credit card in canada usa credit card numbers instant approval credit cards for bad credit uk free vector credit card logos how to buy apps for iphone 4 without credit card easy credit card to get approved for canadian reward credit cards comparison retail advantage credit card processing very poor credit loans best credit card to apply for first time bank of ireland visa debit card 2012 bank of america small business credit card application business credit cards canada compare barclay credit card contact details alaska airlines bank of america credit card phone number pay citifinancial credit card online sear credit card pay online virgin credit card fees abroad alaska airlines credit card visa signature unsecured loans with no guarantor for bad credit walmart ge credit card make payment canadian tire credit card is it better to consolidate credit card debt premium credit cards comparison credit card interest rate calculator monthly download city bank credit card application form starbucks credit cards department store easy to get credit cards bank of america visa credit card payment phone number call center credit card bank mega should i get a credit card to build my credit best credit card deals uae credit card debt after death massachusetts sears mastercard points best credit rebuilding credit cards credit card applications form pdf unsecured loans online bad credit mastercard securecode blocked best interest free credit cards for balance transfers google checkout accepting international credit cards small business no credit loans credit card processing app uk will walmart give me a credit card after bankruptcy walmart credit card payment address mail credit card monthly interest charge calculator best credit cards rewards programs free prepaid credit card worldwide canada credit card processing balance transfer offers uk portable credit card machine singapore how do credit card companies calculate interest charges hsbc student credit card indusind bank credit cards login credit union edinburgh credit cards for very bad credit with no deposit uk how do credit card companies use prime rate disney visa rewards card coupon code td canada trust visa aeroplan capital one credit card reviews 2011 canadian visa cards with the best rewards credit card number and cvv 2013 best cash back mastercard credit cards i need to consolidate my credit cards canara bank credit card online apply best company to consolidate credit cards how to pay off credit card debt how to apply credit card in bdo for ofw reward cards ks1 online prepaid credit card australia mbna canada credit cards login zero percent interest credit cards uk halifax student credit card ppi credit cards longest interest free period merchant credit card processing companies canada my virgin credit card account login best credit card online protection toys r us gold card change of address credit card for no credit or bad credit buy prepaid credit card online with paypal best secured loan for bad credit icici bank hpcl platinum credit card details cibc visa cards benefits line of credit loans online cibc credit card online number best credit card offer in malaysia 2013 rebuild credit cards secured classifying credit card accounts for business intelligence and decision making free credit card authorization form .doc compare credit cards for travel points citibank corporate credit card whats a good first credit card to get current walmart credit card promotions icici bank new credit card apply online how to get a loan with bad credit score same day online payday loans canada credit card fraud detection using hidden markov model ppt secure credit card data storage best travel reward credit card uk credit card information stolen at restaurant mba credit cards uk easy store credit cards 2012 american express delta credit card promotion what happens to credit card debt when you die uk unsecured credit cards for poor credit with no fees low interest credit cards canada balance transfer title loan online quote money magazine best credit cards travel loans with bad credit history and no guarantor paypal credit card rates cash loans online with monthly payments how to get free credit reports without credit card best credit cards travel rewards 2011 check the status of my walmart credit card application us credit cards that work in uk secured credit card for bad credit 2013 what payment purposes are credit cards used for real credit card numbers 2013 that work best credit card merchant services rates bad credit business unsecured credit cards canadian credit card travel comparisons should i consolidate my credit cards with a loan visa cards hsbc platinum credit card uk best cash back business credit cards credit card review india 2012 diners club international credit card top cash rewards credit card faxless online payday loans no credit check credit cards for bad credit unsecured card bmo mastercard insurance standard chartered credit card helpline how do i calculate how much interest i will pay on a credit card capital one credit card to rebuild your credit intuit android credit card reader victoria secret credit card payment address hsbc best buy canada credit card reloadable prepaid visa cards uk first premier bank platinum credit card application status want to apply for hdfc credit card online 24 month interest free credit cards visa credit card approval for bad credit security code on mastercard debit card tesco credit card minimum monthly payment personal loans with bad credit and no bank account hdfc diners club international credit card long term loans with bad credit online bank of america credit card visa login do corporate credit cards affect credit score best cashback cards 2013 sbi gold credit card rewards credit card numbers and security codes that work online us credit card use in canada ann taylor master credit card payment login best low credit credit cards bank of america business credit cards rewards capital one credit card sign in pay us bank corporate credit card canadian visa credit cards pay hdfc bank credit card bill online best low interest no fee credit cards bad credit credit card uk payday loans uk compare low interest rate credit cards for balance transfers different types of credit cards in australia icici bank credit cards online lowest apr credit cards 2012 i want to pay my lane bryant credit card online best credit card offer 2013 credit card 0 apr where can i buy a manual credit card machine easy personal loans with bad credit does applying for too many credit cards hurt your credit score best post bankruptcy credit cards 2012 how old do you have to be to apply for a walmart credit card credit card apr formula portable credit card machines for business credit card apply now check chase credit card application status 2012 credit card protection plans uk how do i take a cash advance on my capital one credit card standard chartered credit card application rejected how do i pay my american airlines credit card instant transfer payday loan lender citi corporate credit card online sbi credit card loan interest rate wells fargo health advantage credit card program best reward credit cards 2012 no annual fee how long does it take to get credit card from capital one axis bank credit card apply online top 10 cash back credit cards in india best international travel credit card 2013 credit card travel insurance compare nedbank personal loans online application legitimate payday lenders online southwest credit card visa signature vijaya bank visa debit card online registration td visa student credit card chase visa credit card services login easy to get department store credit cards 2012 how to get a credit card limit increase capital one orchard credit card contact information fast payday loans no credit check uk direct payday loan lenders with no credit check where can i pay my jcpenney credit card walmart credit card app for android credit card machines for iphone uk what credit card can i apply for hdfc credit card rate of interest on emi canadian credit cards with cash rewards vanilla mastercard not working list of most popular credit cards what is a bad credit score to buy a car us bank credit card payment center what to do with old credit card machine rewards credit cards with no foreign transaction fee southwest credit card offer interest free credit card 24 months credit card no history check united mileage credit card promotion credit card protection act wiki how do i sign up for a bank of america credit card balance transfer natwest to halifax platinum credit card bank of ireland black card magazine uk how to pay hdfc credit card bill payment online capital one credit limit increase policy credit card with best rewards for gas cash advances direct lenders no teletrack hsbc balance transfer form td canada trust cash back visa free credit card information that works best credit cards for bad credit uk hsbc credit cards apply online chase southwest credit card login credit card machine rental uk where to get mortgage loans with bad credit business accepting credit cards student visa credit card chase hdfc new credit card activation 0 percent transfer fee credit cards santander credit card transfer to bank account bank rakyat credit card promotion total visa credit card application small business credit cards free credit card numbers that work with security code and expiration date 2014 maximum interest rate on credit cards in canada ann taylor mastercard credit card online verifone credit card machine paper best reward credit cards for college students lifetime free credit card hdfc bank payday loans online prepaid credit card canada post chase iphone credit card reader personal bank loan to pay off credit card debt unsecured credit cards bad credit apply for business credit cards online fast cash loans online no credit checks hdfc gold credit card limit increase unsecured credit cards bad credit instant approval manual credit card machines uk credit card travel promotion 2013 is capital one a good credit card to build credit where do i send my capital one credit card payment best credit cards for fair credit best credit card with airmiles rewards credit card interest freeze letter paypal accept credit cards visa credit card number list easy store credit cards to get approved for 2013 credit card payment app for iphone credit card services rbs phone number best travel reward credit card no annual fee 0 credit card offers on purchases credit card ratings chase sapphire best visa cards for bad credit visa credit card application japan reward credit cards 2013 amazon visa card review marriott rewards credit cards uk top ten best credit cards for college students credit card scams in new york cheap instant online loans superstore president;s choice credit card first financial bank usa credit card highest credit card limit in india free credit card machine for phones what;s the best travel reward credit card visa cards numbers 2012 free balance transfer offers australia toys r us credit card login ge credit card repayment calculator excel+uk ask capital one credit limit increase best credit card payment processing companies credit card limit hsbc malaysia do car dealers accept credit cards uk horizon gold card application manly council credit card authorisation form chase accept credit cards online best travel credit cards canada 2013 visa card services rental car insurance quick personal online loans nationwide bad credit bank accounts usaa credit card activation number us bank credit card review capital one credit card fraud alert can u apply for a walmart credit card online transfer credit card balance 0 interest ireland new payday lenders only icici credit card points offers can you use visa debit cards in europe credit card debt relief canada business credit card comparison site intuit gopayment mobile credit card processing instant credit card application approval pay ge credit card online what credit card is best in europe is consolidating credit card debt a good idea can i get a firestone credit card with bad credit how do i get a credit card with a high limit jquery credit card number validator credit cards for bad credit with no deposit or processing fee visa card canada number average household credit card debt uk credit card fraud penalties in new york does applying for credit cards hurt your credit visa student credit card reviews southwest rapid rewards credit card worth it credit card fraud insurance starbucks gold card singapore costco credit card machines small business merchant credit card processing no credit check bad credit loans uk instant decision visa cards canada best largest credit card companies uk venture capital 1 credit card how to make hdfc credit card payment online from other bank sbi credit card online payment login hsbc air miles credit card uk check my credit score for free no credit card american express starwood credit card foreign transaction fee ways to reduce credit card debt faster security credit card wallet hsbc credit card settlement process credit card application online hdfc ge credit cards australia prepaid credit cards canada shoppers drug mart first premier credit card limit increase best store credit cards canada guaranteed bad credit loans no fees us bank credit card application status travel credit card offers get fast cash loans now first data credit card machine fd50 manual low limit credit cards for bad credit top canadian student credit cards can you apply for a best buy credit card online mbna credit card deals for existing customers best air miles credit card uk online valid visa credit card number generator does paypal accept international credit cards credit card merchant fees singapore how to get your credit cards paid off fast instant long term loans online mbna low interest credit card non secured credit card bad credit mbna credit card customer services halifax marriott rewards credit card login best credit card abroad 2013 credit card holder ebay india stand alone credit card terminal need a credit card now and have bad credit best travel credit cards 2012 chase disney visa card natwest business credit card phone number free credit card machine for business visa prepaid credit card uk credit card payments with paypal number to activate usaa credit card how to get a small loan with bad credit and no bank account halifax credit card balance transfer promotional code prepaid credit card uk money saving expert top credit card issuers a fake visa credit card number that work best cashback credit cards with no annual fee apply credit card online abn amro gold credit card travel insurance commonwealth best rate credit cards uk best credit cards canada balance transfers bank of america credit card no interest 12 months best credit card rates with no annual fee discover credit card review 2013 unsecured instant approval credit cards for bad credit uk credit card market share 2011 credit card foreign transaction fee comparison uk can you apply for a target credit card online best credit card to get to improve credit score us bank cash plus credit card review how to apply for a credit card online hdfc credit card payment options from hdfc bank 0 balance transfer credit card for bad credit hdfc credit card credit login what does guaranteed to your credit card for late arrival mean canadian tire credit card application canada guaranteed unsecured canadian credit cards virgin credit card uk phone number how does credit card interest work monthly best credit card for earning travel miles free prepaid visa credit cards personal loans online instant approval track discover credit card application how does the toys r us gold card work online hdfc credit card apply status is it worth getting a victoria;s secret credit card nordstrom visa credit card statement all major credit cards vector online payday loan lenders canada home depot business rewards credit cards how do preloaded credit cards work valero business gas credit card easiest retail credit card to get 2013 free credit card information that works 2012 top travel credit card deals online cash advance lenders no teletrack can you get a small business credit card with bad credit sears credit cards phone number westpac credit cards travel insurance long term loans with bad credit instant free credit card icons png chase visa gift card online tesco bank credit cards elh online servicing new starbucks platinum card anz business credit cards rewards credit card merchant account canada sbi credit card payment through debit card most secure credit card reader credit card processing software pc visa student credit card bank of america how to get a refund via credit card best buy credit card payments due top 5 credit card processors most popular credit cards in us best credit cards for college students nab low rate credit card fees can prepaid credit cards be used online free cell phones with no credit check and no creditcard needed virgin credit card sign in uk united chase credit card for business best banks for credit card consolidation loans ge financial services credit card orchard bank credit card activation phone number nab low rate credit card balance transfer can you get prepaid credit cards at cvs virtual credit card paypal uk dubai first credit card uae guaranteed payday loan direct lender nab gold card travel insurance citibank credit card cash advance atm discover credit card joint account disney reward credit card shell credit card malaysia large credit card debt help top payday lenders no credit check balance transfer offers for existing customers top ten best credit cards 2012 how to use a credit card to build credit quickly government home loans with bad credit sbi credit card reward points best rewards credit card 2011 lifehacker credit card payment machine uk credit card number visa or mastercard thomas cook credit card payment charges visa credit card fees for merchants best gas credit card for bad credit reloadable prepaid credit cards walmart free student credit cards bad credit student loans to consolidate credit card debt best first credit card to get 2013 how can i increase my chase freedom credit limit fast payday loans online does chase offer a secured credit card is there an app to pay best buy credit card hdfc bank credit card netsafe login chase secured credit card 2013 activate your td visa card capital city credit card payment shell credit cards india shell gas credit card stolen manual credit card machine how to use td canada trust credit card 0 purchase credit cards 24 months hsbc credit card online application malaysia capital one credit card cash advance limit payday loans online bad credit payday loans best credit card with 0 apr on balance transfers can you store credit cards on iphone virgin credit card ppi questionnaire tesco ireland credit cards online cheapest way to accept credit cards small business hdfc credit card apply in bangalore credit card debt advice forum credit card offers for existing customers chase credit card application status line credit card transfer how do i cancel my canadian tire credit card mis sold ppi post office credit card how to apply for a hsbc credit card in india credit card credit balance transfer bank of america platinum plus visa cash back is it a good idea to pay off credit card debt with a personal loan credit card debt after death uk best credit cards for students traveling abroad credit card canada non resident compare chase and capital one credit cards best hotel rewards credit cards 2012 cibc credit cards canada visa international credit card bangladesh secured credit card in canada cibc icici bank credit card bill payment costco credit card payment login city bank credit card customer care toll free tesco credit card balance transfer existing customers visa business card for bad credit barclays credit card payment protection claim credit card search uk westpac credit card balance transfer rate coast capital lost credit card top 10 credit card issuers in india free fake visa credit card number chase circuit city credit card online payment natwest credit card charges refunded pc richards credit card phone number mastercard priceless campaign best credit card balance transfer offers for existing customers secured bank of america credit card review vanilla mastercard activation credit card loan hdfc bank standard chartered credit card application status contact number which credit card is best in malaysia cheap virtual credit cards credit card travel insurance review best low interest business credit card best credit card for students 2013 citibank credit card dial an emi calculator best us chip and pin credit card ikea credit card apply online business credit card balance transfer 0 balance transfer credit cards explained credit rating icici credit card online payment through icici debit card credit card reward programs carry risks paypal recurring payments via credit card best prepaid credit card for business low credit card rates for students hdfc credit card online application status best student credit card to get check visa credit card application status anz low rate credit card balance transfer get a visa credit card today what to do with old credit card machines how to get out of credit card debt legally amscot cash advance how it works gap visa credit card login how to eliminate credit card debt on your own easiest way to accept credit card payments natwest gold credit card can you use walmart credit card at murphy usa apply for a mastercard usa best place to apply for first credit card us government help with credit card debt credit card insurance necessary icici bank credit card application status online easy cash loans for unemployed sample credit card fax authorization form credit card cash advance charges malaysia sign online payday loans uk contact capital one credit cards best online payday loans yahoo chase united airlines mileage plus credit card login good credit card to rebuild credit anz platinum card travel insurance claim form payday loans uk no fees best current airline credit card offers td canada trust credit card activation number credit limit on very account visa gift cards balance barclays credit card payment address what credit card is best for no credit free credit card payment authorization form template my capital credit card account how to make walmart credit card payments online santander credit card application process capital one credit limit increase how long capital one credit card customer service contact number what is the best first time credit card to get zero interest credit cards transfer balance cash advance online lenders hdfc credit card bill payment help desk best department store credit cards for bad credit 2012 woolworths everyday rewards prepaid credit card best instant loans online unsecured bad credit loan reviews 0 percent interest balance transfer credit card 0 credit card balance transfers and purchases commonwealth bank credit card rental car insurance credit card online abn amro best credit card reader for android tablet lowest interest credit card malaysia online payday loan companies canada recurring credit card payments with paypal credit card processing for small business with bad credit best payday lenders hsbc credit cards online statement free valid credit card numbers with cvv and expiration date top cashback credit cards in canada 2012 bpi credit card online application philippines payday loans online no credit check canada pay bank of america credit card with wells fargo chase student credit cards with no credit bank of america credit card credit check how to prevent credit card fraud in hotels chase credit card a chase mastercard credit card login tata capital credit card login disney credit card chase reviews bad credit payday loans canada usa credit card capital one bad credit credit card compare loans bad credit rating statute of limitations on credit card debt in idaho instant credit card decisions online credit card exchange rates abroad westpac low rate credit card balance transfer credit card travel insurance comparison canada travel reward credit card reviews hdfc credit card bill online payment india where to buy prepaid credit cards in stores pay high interest credit cards first home depot canada credit card best travel credit card in india hsbc student credit card apply best airline credit card deals 2013 how to get a car loan with bad credit and no cosigner citibank platinum credit card compare get american express black card requirements gas credit cards with bad credit 3 types of credit cards verifone vx510 credit card machines easy payday loan cash advances you advance america best no fee credit card offers jd powers credit card ratings 2012 bad credit car finance nottingham how long after bankruptcy can i get a credit card canada nandos black card ebay can you pay best buy credit cards with gift cards icici bank platinum credit card apply online hsbc credit card interest free installment costco credit card processing discovery credit card south africa old fashioned credit card machine virgin money credit cards balance transfer icici credit cards application status top 10 cash back credit cards 2012 immediate cash advance vanquis credit card review chase freedom best credit card protection policy compare credit cards offers in india can i use capital one credit card in canada credit card rates citibank gold credit card online apply cash online loans uk zero interest rate balance transfer credit cards vanilla mastercard gift card balance where can i buy virtual credit card credit card rewards programs wiki what is the issue number on a natwest credit card how to make a door lock credit card proof how to jimmy a door lock with a credit card amazon credit card payment problems best wireless credit card machines platinum delta credit card review i have no credit what credit card can i get amazon credit card points rewards visa credit card low interest no annual fee my visa black card credit card for very bad credit rating black card amex annual fee credit card apply online in indian bank best ways to pay off credit card debt o interest credit cards australia payday lenders bad credit no brokers which credit card is best for me with bad credit household bank credit card capital one no upfront fee credit card bad credit halifax credit card ppi claim address what is a credit card machine used for credit card interest calculator monthly standard chartered credit card malaysia credit card 0 apr for 12 months activate cibc credit card online 0 balance transfers explained natwest credit card customer services contact number bad credit payday loans guaranteed approval direct lenders delta credit card promotion deutsche bank credit cards india chase marriott rewards credit cards login online loan application software tesco credit card change of address best 0 balance transfer secured credit card with cashback rewards how long before credit limit increase capital one balance transfer cards for good credit what is cash advance on a credit card wells fargo navy federal credit union login 3d secure credit card track standard chartered credit card application status easyjet credit card booking fees new hdfc credit card apply emergency loans with no job and bad credit applying for a credit card after chapter 7 bankruptcy black credit card natwest 5 cashback grocery credit card credit cards for good credit scores uk chase freedom credit limit increase citibank credit card bookmyshow offer first premier credit card pay bill online icici new credit card offers best iphone credit card app how to get rid of bad credit card debt romanian credit card fraudsters prepaid credit cards walmart canada citifinancial credit card payment pre approved credit card chase standard chartered credit card customer care number in pune google uk credit card comparison best credit card to get for college student united cash loans phone numbers bank of america joint credit card disney reward credit card by chase high risk credit cards unsecured canada southwest airlines credit card review 2012 pay best buy credit card with another credit card credit card rates australia interest free credit card transfer australia major credit card with low interest rate hdfc credit card settlement letter format how do you apply for a credit card with bad credit best balance transfer credit cards for poor credit pay hdfc credit card bill online billdesk credit card fraud bust in brooklyn chase british airways credit card- 100k avios bonus points prepaid credit cards online gambling can i use square to accept credit cards online uk credit card companies list how do i stop credit card applications secured credit cards with no annual fee best rewards cards 2013 citibank credit card apply eligibility best cashback credit cards 2011 longest 0 apr credit cards 2013 cash back visa credit card pay banana republic visa credit card online smart ways to pay off credit card debt what is a bad credit score uk my vanilla visa card emergency cash loans now apply target credit card online application capital one credit card payment online loan shop online payday loan citibank credit card login india car loan with bad credit score bank of america credit card $500 cash back best us airways business credit card offer chase online credit card services login bp visa credit card application use paypal to buy virtual credit card wireless credit card machine singapore gold credit card means cheapest credit card for purchases new credit card charges sunday premier credit card processing fee best 0 credit cards on purchases compare hdfc bank credit cards credit card information stolen 2013 hdfc bank credit card online banking login prepaid credit cards visa walmart us bank credit card pay online compare malaysian credit card how can i get a credit card today improving a credit card fraud detection system using genetic algorithm change apple credit card what is account cash advance limit visa credit cards no interest ge go mastercard top unsecured credit cards for poor credit search visa credit card number does the post office accept credit cards for money orders prepaid credit card paypal uk visa cards canada lane bryant credit card contact santander student credit cards uk secured credit cards for bad credit scores transfer balance credit cards no fee credit card consolidation services halifax credit card balance transfer code credit card online application icici bank low rate balance transfer credit cards australia fast cash loans london 2 cash back cards names of different types of credit cards instant loans pay back over 12 months do i need a credit card to have an itunes account list of direct cash advance lenders orchard credit card contact info i need a credit card but i have bad credit and no bank account online credit card prepaid paypal check walmart credit card approval did virgin credit cards sell ppi do valero gas stations take credit cards are citi credit cards good when applying for a credit card what do banks look at need a loan with bad credit and no bank account apply for costco credit card canada credit card promotions 2011 philippines get paypal account without credit card bank account hsbc platinum mastercard credit cards walmart credit card payment calculator do i need a credit card to sell on ebay natwest credit card online services hdfc credit card balance transfer how to use a credit card machine uk visa credit card numbers that work with cvv credit card rate increase hdfc credit card reward points value average us credit card debt 2013 capital one credit card credit balance capital one secured credit card increase sign up for credit card first time how does an online purchase with a credit card work marriott credit card review uk chase credit card fraud prevention number southwest airline credit card deals visa credit card account number free credit card payment gateway india easy to get credit cards with high limits how to get free stuff online without a credit card scotiabank american express gold card review joint credit card application chase review best credit card reward programs credit card limit enhancement application format bank of america credit card debt consolidation credit card visa mastercard number credit card numbers uk capital one cash credit card no foreign transaction fee united airline credit cards with no annual fee is interest paid on a credit card tax deductible can individual apply for business credit card credit cards with free travel insurance singapore credit card account number visa free online credit card processing credit card number validation javascript online credit cards immediate use no foreign transaction fee credit cards canada where can i get a prepaid credit card today capital one credit card bonus offer td canada trust credit card contact us pay lic premium online using credit cards cash loans now iphone credit card reader paypal credit card payment api best online cash advance reviews amazon credit card payments ge british airways credit card offer 2011 mbna bank canada credit cards fast payday loans uk good and bad things about credit cards use visa rewards card amazon alaska usa credit card review credit card interest rates going up 2013 is the southwest rapid rewards credit card worth it gold credit card wiki best delta credit card promotion pay standard chartered credit card bill from icici bank credit card visa number credit cards for bad credit unsecured capital one credit card comparisons south africa bank united credit card login westpac low rate credit card minimum income citibank aadvantage credit card 50000 bank of america credit cards for good credit government help with credit card debt 2010 bank of america credit card bonus cash back paypal credit card fees australia lowest interest credit card india department store easy credit cards credit card 0 balance transfer poor credit credit cards free withdrawals abroad credit card rate for life how to protect your credit card from rfid scanners best payday loans no credit check reviews easy credit card southwest credit card login can credit card company garnish income tax refund hdfc credit card irctc offer loans online with monthly payments how to apply credit card in sbi best credit card processing companies for small businesses cash advance credit card fees wells fargo tesco 0 purchase credit cards citibank credit card review malaysia best air mile credit cards uk fast online payday loans canada anz credit card travel insurance review hsbc platinum credit card online application bank of america visa black card cancel discover credit card application direct payday lenders only bad credit best no-fee cash back credit cards in canada fast cash loans today sears canada credit card lost secured credit cards to rebuild credit canada unsecured credit card canada amazon chase credit card international fees how to find your credit card number on visa chase credit cards no interest credit card deal blog best travel credit card 2012 canada can get chase credit card bad credit credit card to build credit canada the best rewards credit card in canada credit card prepaid canada southwest rapid rewards credit card deals student credit cards canada old orchard credit card phone number verifone credit card machine help register my visa gift card online free pay as you go credit card visa disney world credit card reviews sunday school reward cards natwest credit card services 0800 payday cash advances in georgia hdfc credit card payment options neft credit card charges refund chase credit card minimum payment due natwest credit card 0 barclays credit card payment dubai chase secured credit card visa top rated canadian credit cards interest free credit card uk american express blue card credit limits cibc dividend credit card login us average credit card interest rate apply for capital one prepaid credit card amazon visa credit card application status 0 interest credit cards for 24 months credit card terminal paper rolls sears credit card customer service hsbc best value credit card usaa world mastercard post office credit card dollar exchange rate no credit credit cards no deposit best credit cards 2011 for good credit citibank credit card payment machine credit cards no annual fee low apr fair credit national city bank credit card payment axis bank credit card reward points gift can you purchase gift cards with a walmart credit card credit card to build credit score after bankruptcy credit cards canada no fee low apr credit cards same day payday loans lenders only virgin credit card minimum payment calculator credit card offer on samsung mobile standard chartered credit card reward points pakistan free credit card reader for android phone citi secured mastercard credit card application quickbooks accept credit cards online sbi online credit card payment options ipad credit card processing app uk short term credit card terminal hire citibank credit card free travel insurance prepaid credit card with no international fees how do i get a secured credit card with bad credit activate walmart debit visa card paypal mobile credit card processing reviews what are the typical merchant credit card processing fees do i need a credit card number for apple id track hsbc credit card application status citibank credit card application for ofw ebay credit card offers oct 2013 unsecured student credit cards no credit best credit card for balance transfer with poor credit ann taylor credit card payments online qantas frequent flyer credit cards comparison reloadable visa cards canada list of online store credit cards activate gold card hostelworld credit cards and bad credit how to commit credit card fraud and not get caught what is the best chase credit card for students credit cards with the best rewards programs 2013 arco gas station credit card application is it bad for your credit to apply for multiple credit cards credit card reward offers royal bank of canada avion visa card american express gold card credit limit shell gas credit card services best cash back no fee credit card what is the maximum credit limit in a vanquis card secured credit card no credit check required nab platinum credit card travel insurance online prepaid credit card canada international credit card processing service fake visa credit card number and expiration date apply for all credit cards at once quickbooks mobile credit card processing ge money pc richards credit card login new small business credit card offers what type of credit cards can i apply for credit cards no credit history required secured credit cards with rewards credit card company liable faulty goods capital one ca credit card guaranteed money magazine best of the best credit cards fatwallet which credit card should i get tesco credit card ppi success chase credit card services capital one secured credit card td visa gm card contact capital one secured credit cards in canada virgin credit card 0 apr unsecured credit cards for bad credit instant approval no deposit is it easy to get approved for a best buy credit card toys r us gold card butlins compare rewards cards canada bank of america credit card cash advance checks cash rewards credit cards standard chartered credit card loan calculator cheapest credit card terminal ireland free nandos black card best low interest rate credit cards 2013 100 guaranteed payday loans for bad credit mastercard prepaid business card how do visa cash advances work best way to accept credit cards online fake visa credit card verification code gas credit cards with cash back what is the best gas credit card for bad credit standard chartered credit card bill payment gateway best buy credit card apply lowest interest rate credit card malaysia consolidating credit card debt through credit union credit card number format wikipedia citibank credit card rewards sg top credit cards barclays credit card payments online is there a time limit on disputing credit card charges best prepaid credit card for europe credit card interest rates government travel credit card citibank unsecured credit card companies for bad credit top 10 credit card issuers in canada natwest how long to get a credit card does bad credit affect company credit card anz low rate credit card how to close a capital one credit card no interest credit card capital one best american airlines credit card offer 2012 citibank credit card limit calculator list of visa rewards cards hdfc signature credit cards reward points anz low interest credit card nz discovery credit card rewards hudson bay company credit card application when does first premier credit card report to credit bureaus credit card online payment icici visa student credit card application credit card bad credit credit cards for poor credit with no processing fee us airways mastercard companion ticket hsbc credit card interest free stores sears credit cards login icici bank credit card loan interest rate balance transfer credit card deals australia how to start an online payday loan business bank of america credit card minimum payment increase all major credit cards accepted logo best travel credit card in canada 2013 chase credit card security department bad credit loans guaranteed approval south africa air miles credit card canada welcome to your tesco credit card online hsbc credit cards application form balance transfer credit card no fee no interest chase amazon business visa credit card lufthansa miles and more credit card canada best travel credit card 2011 australia best business credit cards for international travel aadvantage credit card offers 2011 wells fargo small business secured credit card hdfc online credit card application form highest credit limit on credit card is magnum cash advance legal in florida platinum credit card hdfc bank credit card approval process in india rapid cash payday loans kissimmee apple vacations credit card reviews mousehunt cherry credits cards credit card fraud detection system disney visa card meet and greet hsbc credit card online application status india payday loan lenders only online us bank rei credit card logon neiman marcus credit card customer service phone number capital one hsbc credit card business credit check for renting which one is the best credit card rewards program best guaranteed credit card canada credit card default rates uk american express membership rewards gift cards secured credit cards canada bmo visa low rate credit cards best balance transfer credit cards martin lewis
PUBLIC LANDS FOR THE PEOPLE File Lawsuit Against SB 670 PDF Print E-mail
Monday, 16 November 2009

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

PUBLIC LANDS FOR THE PEOPLE, INC., a California 501 C-3, non-profit corporation; Gerald E. Hobbs; Patrick Keene; Keene Engineering Co., Inc., a California corporation; Robert Haiduck; Terry Stapp; Dee Stapp; David DeCosta; James Gregory Lee; Mike Holt; Todd Bracken; Shannon Poe; and David Richard,

Plaintiffs,
v.

State of California; Arnold Schwarzenegger, in his official capacity as Governor of the State of California; California Department of Fish & Game; and Donald Koch, in his official capacity as Director, California Department of Fish & Game; and Does 1-20,

Defendants.

CIVIL ACTION NO.
COMPLAINT FOR:

Adjudication of Federal Preemption and Supremacy Relating to the Mining Laws of the United States;
Deprivation of Property Rights and Due Process of Law; Denial of Equal Protection of the Laws; Taking of Property Without Compensation; Violation of Civil Rights; Violation of the Mining and Minerals Policy Act of 1970, 30 U.S.C. § 21a; Violation of 30 U.S.C. §§ 21-54 (Mining Act); Violation of Plaintiffs’ Implied Rights to Use Public Lands (Quiet Title); Unlawful Interference With Commerce; Injunctive Relief; and Damages.

DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL

JURISDICTION AND VENUE
1. Jurisdiction is proper in this Court under 28 U.S.C. § 1331 because this action arises under the laws of the United States. The conduct complained of creates an actual, justiciable controversy. The California legislature has passed an act, SB 670, and the Governor of California, the Honorable Arnold Schwarzenegger has signed into law SB 670, prohibiting all motorized mining, including vacuum and suction dredge mining, in the rivers, streams, and waterways of California, in derogation of Federal law authorizing, protecting, and permitting such mining.
2. This Court has jurisdiction, among other matters, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1331 (federal question), §§ 2201, 2202 (declaratory relief), § 2202 (injunctive relief), and § 2409(a) (quiet title).
3. This action arises under the various acts, regulations, laws, and constitutions, as set forth in paragraph 8.
4. This Court has the power to grant declaratory and injunctive relief pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 2201 and 2202.
5. This lawsuit requests judicial review of final actions taken by the Defendants (or their predecessors-in-interest). Defendants’ actions unlawfully abrogate, prescribe, and/or prohibit Federal statutorily prescribed rights of unpatented mining claim owners, miners and prospectors as well as violating Federal statutorily prescribed methods relating to mining and prospecting on Federal lands in the State of California.
6. Defendants are attempting to unlawfully alter the entire Federal regulatory framework for citizens, miners and prospectors in the State of California by adopting a rigid, narrow, and single-focus policy regarding closure of all rivers, streams, and waterways to motorized mining methods, including without limitation, vacuum and suction dredge mining. Defendants failed to consider any meaningful alternatives which could be applied specifically to miners, prospectors, and other citizens who are potential miners and prospectors.
7. This is an action for declaratory judgment, injunctive relief (Rule 65, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure), as well as for damages incurred by Plaintiffs. The Plaintiffs request the Court to declare unlawful, enjoin implementation of, and set aside the promulgation and adoption by the legislature and the Governor of California of the prohibition of all motorized means of mining in the rivers, streams, and waterways of California, including without limitation, vacuum and suction dredge mining, not only as it applies to miners and prospectors, but also all other members of the public who are potential mining claimants, miners and prospectors.
8. The Plaintiffs seek an Order from this Court declaring that Defendants’ actions in adopting and implementing a prohibition of all motorized methods of mining, including without limitation, vacuum and suction dredge mining in the rivers, streams, and waterways of California as applied to miners and prospectors, and those who intend to become miners and prospectors, violated the following:
A. National Environmental Policy Act (“NEPA”), 42 U.S.C. § 4321 et seq. (1969); and Executive Orders: EO 12291 and EO 12866;
B. Multiple Use Sustained Yield Act (“MUSYA”), 16 U.S.C. § 528 et seq. (1960);
C. Numerous sections of the Code of Federal Regulations (“CFR”), as set forth in 36 CFR 228 et seq.; 36 CFR 261 et seq.; 43 CFR 3800; 43 CFR 3809.1 et seq., including without limitation 43 CFR 3809.3; and also including without limitation, numerous other sections of the CFRs regulating mining, prospecting, and associated activities on Federal lands.
D. The Federal Lands Policy and Management Act (“FLPMA”) 43 U.S.C. § 1701 et seq., including without limitation §§ 1732(b), 1761 and 1769;
E. PL No. 104-208, 110 Stat.3009 § 108 (Omnibus Consolidated Appropriations Act of 1997);
F. 30 U.S.C. §§ 21-54 (Mining Act), including without limitation the Mining and Minerals Policy Act of 1970, 30 U.S.C. § 21(a);
G. 16 U.S.C. § 481 (Use of Waters);
H. 30 U.S.C. § 612, 613, 615 (Multiple Surface Use Act);
I. 5 U.S.C. §§ 601, 602, 603(b) and © (Regulatory Flexibility Act As Amended By The Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act of 1996 (5 U.S.C. §§ 801-808) [SBREFA]);
J. The Endangered Species Act 16 U.S.C. § 1531;
K. California Civil Code § 3479 et seq.;
L. California Code of Civil Procedure § 731;
M. The 5th and 14th Amendments to the Constitution of the United States;
N. Article I § 8 (Commerce Clause) of the Constitution of the United States;
O. Article I § 7(a) of the Constitution of California; and
P. Article I § 19 of the Constitution of California.
9. Venue is proper in this Court pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331, 1391(b) and (e), and
because the events and omissions giving rise to Plaintiffs’ claims occurred within this judicial district.

INTRODUCTION
10. This case presents a classic conflict between prospectors, miners who hold unpatented or patented mining claims on Federal lands pursuant to the mining laws of the United States, and the State of California, Department of Fish and Game (“DF&G”). Until recently, DF&G issued permits for vacuum and suction dredge prospecting and mining on such claims for rivers, streams, and waterways in the State of California running through such Federal mining claims and estates, and unclaimed Federal lands open to prospecting and mining.
11. Beginning on August 6, 2009, DF&G would no longer issue permits for vacuum and suction dredge mining on Federal mining claims, and cancelled all such permits previously issued. This had the effect of prohibiting vacuum and suction dredge mining and prospecting in the State of California on all Federal mining claims and lands, and unclaimed lands open to location and entry under the United States mining laws, and unlawfully prohibited the location, utilization and development of mining claims and mineral estates in California. This unlawfully affected and unconstitutionally burdened interstate and foreign commerce, since many of the prospectors, and mining claim and mineral estate owners, are non-residents of California who prospect or work their claims and mineral estates in California with vacuum and suction dredges. This affected not only California residents who are mining claim owners, prospectors and miners, but also non-resident mining claim owners, prospectors and miners who purchased non-resident permits from DF&G in order to engage in vacuum and suction dredge mining in the State of California. This also had the effect of stopping the sale of equipment and accessories for vacuum and suction dredge mining both within and without the State of California. This placed an unlawful, unconstitutional, and undue burden and restriction on interstate and foreign commerce in the sale of the aforesaid mining equipment and accessories.
12. The California DF&G claims authorization to issue permits for vacuum and suction dredge mining in the State of California, even when such mining occurs on Federal lands and is pursuant to the mining laws of the United States. California Fish and Game Code § 5653 et seq.; California Code of Regulations 14 CCR § 228. Waters within the boundaries of Federal lands, including National Forests, National Parks, and lands within the jurisdiction of the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) may be used for mining. 16 U.S.C. § 481. The attempt to stop suction dredge mining in California has a long and tangled history.
13. In 2004, the Karuk Tribe filed suit in the United States District Court in Oakland, California for declaratory and injunctive relief alleging improper management of suction dredge and other mining operations in waterways and riparian areas within the Klamath National Forest. The Karuk Tribe claimed violation of the National Forest Management Act, National Environmental Policy Act, and the Endangered Species Act. Judgment was rendered against the Karuk Tribe and for the defendants. Karuk Tribe of California vs. United States Forest Service, et al., 379 F.Supp.2d 1071 (2005). Anticipating a loss in Federal Court, the Karuk Tribe decided to try their legal luck in State Court. On May 6, 2005, the Karuk Tribe of California filed suit against the California Department of Fish and Game in the Superior Court of Alameda County. Karuk Tribe of California; and Leaf Hillman, Plaintiffs, v. California Department of Fish and Game; and Ryan Broddrick, Director, California Department of Fish and Game, Defendants, Case No. RG 05211597. The case was heard by Judge Bonnie Sabraw. Judge Sabraw is now retired, and the case was transferred to the Honorable Frank Roesch, Judge of the Superior Court, Alameda County. The object of this lawsuit was to stop all suction dredge mining in the Klamath, Scott, and Salmon Rivers, and specified tributaries, supposedly in order to protect Coho salmon. No notice was initially given to any miners that this litigation had been filed. The Karuk Tribe is headquartered on the Klamath River in Happy Camp, California.
14. The California Department of Fish and Game (“DF&G”) at first opposed the allegations of the Karuk Tribe as set forth in its Complaint. Soon however, DF&G decided to capitulate to the Karuk Tribe. DF&G, effective November 30, 2005, issued regulations severely restricting suction dredge mining in the Klamath, Scott, and Salmon Rivers and their tributaries. These regulations specifically referenced the litigation brought by the Karuk Tribe in Alameda County. In addition, the Karuk Tribe and DF&G presented to Judge Sabraw a “Proposed Stipulated Judgment,” and later a modified “Proposed Stipulated Judgment,” which would have enjoined and restrained DF&G from issuing permits for suction dredge mining “for the Klamath, Salmon, and Scott Rivers, their tributaries and thermal refugia.”
15. The first that the miners heard of the State Court litigation filed by the Karuk Tribe in Alameda County was approximately December 7, 2005, when they were refused suction dredge mining permits by DF&G affecting the whole State of California, because of the Karuk Tribe litigation. At this stage, Judge Sabraw had issued no order authorizing such prohibition. DF&G did this without any rule making authority or process whatsoever, or in compliance with any court order.
16. The mining claim owners and miners who were denied permits by DF&G contacted Mr. Hobbs, as President of PLP, and informed him of their situation. Mr. Hobbs informed other mining groups of the Karuk Tribe litigation, and the unilateral and unauthorized prohibitions placed on suction dredge mining in California by DF&G. Mr. Hobbs requested the Court not to sign the Proposed Stipulated Judgment (“PSJ”). In 2006, Mr. Hobbs, and another mining organization, were allowed by Judge Sabraw to intervene in the Karuk Tribe litigation. Mr. Hobbs immediately set about opposing the PSJ which the Karuk Tribe and DF&G had presented to Judge Sabraw.
17. After extensive briefings and hearings by all parties, on June 16, 2006, Judge Sabraw issued the Court’s “Order Denying Motion to Enter Judgment.” Judge Sabraw specifically found that the PSJ which would have prohibited suction dredge mining in the Klamath, Scott, and Salmon Rivers, and their tributaries, “was contrary to law and public policy.”
18. DF&G initially opposed the Karuk Tribe in the litigation before Judge Sabraw. However, DF&G has openly admitted that it does not want to be the agency administering suction dredge mining in California. Seeing an opportunity to rid itself of issuing permits for suction dredge mining, DF&G decided to switch horses in mid-stream.
19. Thereafter, DF&G changed its position and filed two affidavits from its officials and employees asserting that suction dredge mining could have an adverse effect on Coho Salmon in the litigation relating to the Klamath, Scott, and Salmon Rivers. The miners strongly disputed any such alleged admissions of DF&G.
20. No miner in California would ever rely on DF&G to protect his or her interest. The mining community in California has no confidence in DF&G to protect their interest in anything relating to mining.
21. Judge Sabraw encouraged all parties to enter into settlement negotiations. After two meetings in Sacramento, and much blood, sweat, and tears, all parties were finally able to reach settlement of the Karuk Tribe litigation. On December 20, 2006, Judge Sabraw entered the Court’s Order and Consent Judgment. The heart of the Court’s December 20, 2006, Order and Consent Judgment was that DF&G will conduct a review relating to the Klamath, Scott, and Salmon Rivers, pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (“CEQA”), Public Resources Code § 21000 et seq., which was to be completed within 18 months. During this period, suction dredge mining was to be permitted in the Klamath, Scott, and Salmon Rivers, and their tributaries. All requests for injunctive relief against DF&G barring suction dredge mining were withdrawn pending such environmental review. Thus, suction dredge mining continued pending an environmental determination as to whether any prohibition whatsoever would be justified.
22. The heart of Judge Sabraw’s Order and Consent Judgment reads as follows:
“THEREFORE, the Department is hereby ORDERED to conduct a further environmental review pursuant to CEQA of its suction dredge mining regulations and to implement, if necessary, via rulemaking, mitigation measures to protect the Coho salmon and/or other special status fish species in the watershed of the Klamath, Scott, and Salmon Rivers, listed as threatened or endangered after the 1994 EIR.”

23. The aforesaid review was to be completed within eighteen months, and the Court retained jurisdiction of the matter. DF&G was not able to complete the review in the time frame set by Judge Sabraw, claiming (a) that they could not do an EIR limited to only the Klamath, Scott and Salmon Rivers, but had to do an all inclusive statewide EIR; and (b) further claiming that the California financial crisis prevented it from being funded by the legislature to complete the DF&G unilaterally expanded statewide review. There is now pending a hearing before Judge Roesch to hold DF&G and its Director, Donald Koch, in contempt for failing to timely complete the DF&G inspired statewide review.
24. The two suspect affidavits filed by DF&G turned out to cost the State $230,000.00. The Karuk Tribe later filed a motion for attorneys fees against DF&G, who, after negotiations, agreed to and did pay the Karuk Tribe $230,000.00. The Karuk Tribe agreed to seek no further attorneys fees in the litigation before Judge Sabraw.
25. Although the Karuk Tribe consented to the judgment entered by Judge Sabraw on December 20, 2006, the Karuk Tribe then became an initiator and supporter of new legislation, AB 1032, which supposedly was meant to protect trout by prohibiting suction dredge gold mining in approximately sixty-eight rivers throughout California, including the Klamath, Scott, and Salmon Rivers. AB 1032 was unusual in referring numerous times to the Karuk Tribe litigation in Alameda County, still then pending before Judge Sabraw. AB 1032 by its terms was to remain in effect until January 1, 2011, unless DF&G has completed the CEQA environmental review prior to that date which has been mandated by Judge Sabraw in the Karuk Tribe litigation in Alameda County. Thus, the heart of AB 1032 was to prohibit suction dredge gold mining in sixty-eight rivers throughout California, including the Klamath, Scott, and Salmon Rivers, and their tributaries, until the CEQA environmental review is completed. This stood Judge Sabraw’s December 20, 2006, Order and Consent Judgment on its head.
26. Judge Sabraw refused to prohibit any such suction dredge mining, including gold mining, until the environmental review was completed. The environmental review had to be completed first in order to see whether or not any such prohibition would be justified. Even in the unlikely event an environmental review would justify suction dredge mining prohibitions in the Klamath, Scott, and Salmon Rivers; any such prohibition set forth in AB 1032 would be immediately repealed upon the completion of the environmental review ordered by Judge Sabraw. AB 1032 was inherently illogical, since it applied only to suction dredge gold mining, and allowed all other types of suction dredge mining, including mining for silver, copper, lead,
mercury, and other heavy metals and precious and semi-precious gems. However, AB 1032’s inherently illogical provisions were not its chief fault and defect.
27. AB 1032 was meant to subvert Judge Sabraw’s court order permitting suction dredge mining, including gold mining, in the Klamath, Scott, and Salmon Rivers pending an environmental review. AB 1032 was special, private, legislation that enhanced the Karuk Tribe’s economic and political position in a way that Judge Sabraw, after hearings and consideration, refused to sanction.
28. Plaintiff Gerald E. Hobbs testified before the legislature against the passage of AB 1032. However, AB 1032 was eventually passed and went to Governor Schwarzenegger for his signature. What AB 1032 was meant to do is make Governor Schwarzenegger a party to the subversion of a valid court order. AB 1032 struck at the very heart of a court’s authority to uphold the rule of law. Governor Schwarzenegger vetoed AB 1032.
29. In his veto message, Governor Schwarzenegger stated:
“I am returning Assembly Bill 1032 without my signature. The purpose of this bill is to protect fish and wildlife from the potential deleterious effects of suction dredge mining. Although I appreciate the author’s intent and the need to protect our fish, wildlife, and water resources, this bill is unnecessary. Current law gives the Department of Fish and Game (Department) the necessary authority to protect fish and wildlife resources from suction dredge mining. It has promulgated regulations and issues permits for this activity. Permits for suction dredge mining must ensure that these operations are not deleterious to fish and allow the Department to specify the type and size of equipment to be used. In its regulations, the Department may also designate specific waters or areas that are closed to dredging. It is unclear why this bill specifically targets a number of specific waterways for closure or further restrictions. The listed waterways represent only a small fraction of the waters in our State where suction dredging is occurring. The benefit or protection from such a minor closure is negligible and supports the notion that scientific environmental review should precede such decisions.”

30. After Governor Schwarzenegger vetoed AB 1032, legislative allies of the Karuk Tribe then attempted to stop suction dredge mining in California by attaching a prohibition of such mining to the California state budget bill. Governor Schwarzenegger line-item vetoed that attempt.
31. After the stealth attack on suction dredge mining via the state budget failed, the Karuk Tribe then petitioned the Department of Fish & Game to have suction dredge mining prohibited throughout California. DF&G rejected the Karuk Tribe’s petition.
32. This did not stop the Karuk Tribe’s longstanding attempt to end suction dredge mining in California. On February 5, 2009, three members and officials of the Karuk Tribe filed a purported taxpayers action in the Alameda County Superior Court seeking to stop suction dredge mining throughout all of California. Hillman et al. v. California Department of Fish and Game. Case No. RG009 434444. That case was eventually assigned to Judge Roesch, in light of his involvement with the prior Karuk Tribe litigation upon the retirement of Judge Sabraw.
33. After pointing out to the Court that the supposed outraged taxpayer Plaintiffs were really stand-ins for the Karuk Tribe, an amended Complaint was filed consisting of the Karuk Tribe, its three initial members, and a bevy of environmental groups and allies of the Karuk Tribe.
34. The same relief the Karuk Tribe sought in the taxpayer suit, Hillman v. DF&G, supra, could have been brought in the initial case heard by Judge Sabraw, Karuk Tribe v. DF&G, supra. That case is still subject to the Superior Court’s jurisdiction. However, since no further attorneys fees could be obtained in Karuk Tribe v. DF&G, a supposed taxpayers’ suit was initiated with the hope of obtaining further attorney’s fees. The State is concerned that in light of the Preliminary Injunction issued by Judge Roesch, they will be subject to further substantial attorney’s fees.
35. The Karuk Tribe then sought a Preliminary Injunction in the taxpayers’ action before Judge Roesch. On July 10, 2009, Judge Roesch issued a Preliminary Injunction, relying on the two suspect affidavits filed by officials and employees of DF&G relating to Coho salmon in the Klamath, Scott, and Salmon Rivers in the litigation initiated before Judge Sabraw.
36. The Preliminary Injunction ordered by Judge Roesch prohibited the California Department of Fish and Game from issuing any permits for suction dredge mining in every river, stream, and waterway throughout California. Judge Roesch’s Preliminary Injunction applied to every river, stream, and waterway in California irrespective of whether or not they had any Coho salmon in them or indeed any fish at all. Only a small percentage of the rivers, streams, and waterways in California have any salmon in them whatsoever, and a substantially smaller percentage contain any Coho salmon. The Preliminary Injunction ordered by Judge Roesch is presently on appeal.
37. On February 27, 2009, another attempt was made by the Karuk Tribe to circumvent Judge Sabraw’s Order. Allies of the Karuk Tribe introduced SB 670 in the State Senate again seeking to prohibit all suction dredge mining in every river, stream, lake, and waterway in California until a CEQA review had been completed and new regulations were operative. The prohibition would take place whether or not there were Coho salmon, trout, minnows, or any fish whatsoever in any of the State’s waters. SB 670 was, in many respects, a replay of AB 1032.
38. SB 670 was aimed at suction dredge mining, and prohibited the issuance by DF&G of any new permits for suction dredge mining in California. In addition, SB 670 invalidated any prior permits issued by DF&G for suction dredge mining. SB 670 prohibited suction dredge mining in every river, stream, lake, and waterway throughout the State of California, not just the three rivers in the initial suit brought before Judge Sabraw--the Klamath, Scott and Salmon Rivers--nor the 68 rivers and streams targeted in AB 1032. This prohibitory progression is regulation run riot.
39. SB 670 passed the legislature and was sent to Governor Schwarzenegger for his signature. Reversing his position where he vetoed AB 1032, and the attempt to prohibit suction dredge mining through a rider to the state budget. Governor Schwarzenegger signed SB 670 into law. This constituted a triumph of money and raw political power over the laws of the United States, including without limitation, those laws relating to mining on Federal lands.
40. For Plaintiff Public Lands for the People, Inc. (“PLP”), and its members as well as all other Plaintiffs, suction dredge prospecting and mining in the rivers, streams, and waterways of California is not recreational. It is an important economic endeavor that has a direct economic impact on family finances, business finances, and in these hard economic times, often is the difference between having to choose whether to put gas in the car, or buy food or medicine for the family. For PLP and its members, and all other Plaintiffs, suction dredge prospecting and mining is not merely a question of having “fun”. Prohibiting suction dredge mining to prospectors and miners, who are Federal mineral estate grantees, forces them to face serious economic hardship. With a perilous economy, being able to sell even an ounce of gold for over $900.00 makes a substantial difference as to the economic choices a family has regarding basic necessities.
41. Prospecting, placer mining, suction dredge mining, and granted rights of way associated with mining and prospecting activities, all of which are mining operations pursuant to the mining laws and the Code of Federal Regulations (“CFR”), and all of which have valid pre-existing rights pursuant to the mining laws and CFRs, are traditionally common in the State of California, and done in accordance with the rules and customs of miners. Suction dredge mining is the only reasonable, economical, and environmentally sound method for extracting precious metals from the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways in California.
42. Plaintiffs are informed and believe, and thereon allege, that prohibition of vacuum and suction dredge mining has already taken place and is being implemented. DF&G has sent letters to holders of permits validly issued prior to the passage of SB 670 telling them to cease and desist all suction dredge mining in California. DF&G will no longer issue permits for suction dredge mining in California.
43. This has direct and immediate effect upon mining claim owners, prospectors and miners in California, in that they need mechanized methods of mining, including vacuum and suction dredge mining, in the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways of California in order to economically prospect and mine in those rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways, and to engage in other associated mining activities therein. DF&G asserts that permits are needed in order to engage in vacuum or suction dredge mining anywhere in the State of California, whether such mining occurs on private, State, or Federal lands, or pursuant to mining claims authorized by the State of California or the United States, or authorized in any manner whatsoever.
44. Plaintiffs are informed and believe, and thereon allege, that the prohibition of vacuum and suction dredge mining in the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways of California will affect over ninety-five percent (95%) of all mineral production from the aforesaid rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways.
45. The legislature did not consider any alternatives to the prohibition of all motorized means of mining, including vacuum and suction dredge mining, in the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways of California.


SB 670
46. SB 670 adds to the CF&GC a newly enacted Section 5653.1.
47. Present law prohibits the use of any vacuum or suction dredge equipment by any person in any river, stream, or lake in California without a permit issued by DF&G. California Fish and Game Code § 5653 (“CF&GC”). On average, DF&G has issued approximately 3,200 suction dredge mining permits to California residents every year for the last fifteen (15) years. It is estimated that suction dredge miners, resident and non-resident, spend approximately $60,000,000 in the rural counties of California on supplies, fuel, food, camping, equipment, hardware, lodging, goods and services. Any person required to possess a permit pursuant to Section 5653, shall present his or her dredging equipment for inspection upon request of a State or County Fish and Game Warden. CF&GC § 5653.3. For purposes of §§ 5653 and 5653.3, “person” does not include a partnership, corporation, or other type of association. Under existing law, it is unlawful to possess a vacuum or suction dredge in areas, or in or within a hundred yards of waters that are closed to the use of vacuum or suction dredges. A violation of the permit requirement is a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of up to $1,000.00 and six months in jail. CF&GC § 5653 et seq.; 14 CCR § 228 et seq. The Plaintiffs, as well as other miners and prospectors, are concerned that they will be cited for a criminal violation by DF&G should they attempt to engage in vacuum or suction dredge mining, as well as any other motorized mining use.
48. DF&G is authorized to close areas otherwise open for dredging and for which permits have been issued, if there is an unanticipated water level change and the department determines that the closure is necessary to protect wildlife and water resources. 14 CCR § 228. No such determination has been made by DF&G as it relates to SB 670.
49. Existing law requires DF&G to adopt regulations to implement certain of the vacuum and suction dredge equipment requirements, and authorizes the DF&G to issue regulations with respect to other requirements. Existing law requires that the regulations be adopted in accordance with the requirements of CEQA. CF&GC § 5653.9.
50. CEQA requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared by contract, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a “project”, as defined, that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment, or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect. SB 670 declares that the issuance of permits to operate vacuum or suction dredge equipment is a “project” pursuant to CEQA. CF&GC § 5653.1(a).
51. The act exempts from its provisions, among other things, certain types of ministerial projects proposed to be carried out or approved by public agencies, and emergency repairs to public service facilities necessary to maintain service. CF&GC § 21080(b)(1); 14 CCR § 15060©(1). The issuance of permits for vacuum or suction dredge mining authorized by Federal law is a non-discretionary and ministerial act.
52. After SB 670 designated the issuance of permits to operate vacuum or suction dredge equipment to be a “project” under CEQA, it suspended the issuance of permits, including permits issued prior to the passage of SB 670, and any mining pursuant to such permit, until the DF&G has completed an environmental impact report for the “project” as ordered by the Court in Karuk Tribe et al. v. California Department of Fish and Game, et al., Alameda County Superior Court, Case No. RG 05211597. DF&G has stated that it will not complete the Court ordered environmental review of its permitting program until, at the earliest, in the late summer of 2011.
53. SB 670 prohibits the use of any vacuum or suction dredge equipment in any river, stream, or lake, for in-stream mining purposes, until the director of DF&G certifies to the Secretary of State that: 1) The DF&G has completed the environmental review of its existing vacuum or suction dredging regulations as ordered by the Court; 2) DF&G has transmitted for filing with the Secretary of State, a certified copy of new regulations as necessary; and 3) the new regulations are operative. There is no time frame set for this cascade of contingencies, and there is no realistic expectation that they will ever be completed within the next decade, if then.
54. In trying to explain why the completion of the environmental impact report will take so long, DF&G has stated that:
“Q: When will the EIR be completed? DFG is preparing a Subsequent Environmental Impact Report (EIR) to conduct the court-ordered review. DFG estimates at this point that it will complete and certify the Subsequent EIR (and updates to the existing regulations, if necessary) after a series of public meetings and other opportunities for public comment and review by late summer 2011. The environmental review and regulation processes are governed by the California Environmental Quality Act and the Administrative Procedures Act, respectively. The time line is driven by the requirements of these laws.”

“Q: Why is this process going to take so long? DFG has already begun the environmental review necessary to analyze the current regulations; this was last done in 1994. The review process will be complex and lengthy given the statewide scope of the analysis and the time that has passed since the last review. In addition to the detailed written analysis prepared by DFG in coordination with the State Water Board, the review process will also include several opportunities for public involvement, both via public meetings and through solicitation of written comments and suggestions. Initial public meetings to discuss the scope of the environmental analysis are currently being planned for November 2009 in Fresno, Sacramento and Redding. Additional details, including the time and place of the meetings, will be posted on the DFG Web site, www.dfg.ca.gov, as they become available.”

Although the court-ordered review for the EIR is only for the Klamath, Scott, and Salmon Rivers, DF&G will conduct a statewide review for the EIR. DF&G has stated that:
“Based on the information DFG collected from interested parties, DFG informed the Alameda County Superior Court in early 2008 that DFG could not proceed with the court-ordered environmental review in reliance on an addendum to the 1994 EIR. DFG informed the court at the same time that more than minor additions or changes to the 1994 EIR would be necessary and that statewide issues would need to be addressed in a subsequent environmental document in order to fulfill DFG’s obligations under CEQA. As a result, DFG informed the Alameda County Superior Court that it intended to prepare a subsequent or supplemental environmental impact report that would be statewide in scope to comply with the December 2006 Court Order.”

55. SB 670 is declared to be an “urgency statute,” and without support of any credible evidence whatsoever, and without the completion of any environmental impact report the legislature:
“finds that suction or vacuum dredge mining results in various adverse environmental impacts to protected fish species, the water quality of this state, and the health of the people of this state, and, in order to protect the environment and the people of California pending the completion of a court-ordered environmental review by the Department of Fish and Game and the operation of new regulations, as necessary, it is necessary that this act take effect immediately.”

56. Thus, the legislative finding is dependent upon the completion of an environmental impact review (“EIR”) that is yet to take place, and may never take place. If an EIR ever does take place, it will most likely affirm that not one fish has ever been killed or harmed through present day suction dredge mining; that such mining causes no discernable harm to the natural environment of the water resources of the State of California; and is, in fact, beneficial to the environment and natural resources of the State of California. The purported legislative finding is without basis in fact, and is a political, not a scientific conclusion, and is contrary to the scientific evidence that was available to the legislature.
57. DF&G will not issue refunds for those who have purchased permits prior to the passage of SB 670, since SB 670 does not provide for any such refunds.
58. DF&G has stated that vacuum or suction dredge equipment lawfully placed in the waters of California prior to the passage of SB 670 must be immediately removed pursuant to CF&GC § 5563. No compensation is to be provided by the DF&G or SB 670 to any mining claim owner, miner or prospector for the expense of purchasing such equipment, lawfully placing such equipment in the State’s waters, or having to remove such equipment from the waters.


PARTIES
59. Plaintiff Public Lands for the People, Inc. is a California 501 c-3 non-profit corporation (“PLP”). PLP is a nationwide organization of miners, who are mineral estate grantees, and prospectors. With its constituent members, PLP constitutes approximately 40,000 people. Its founder and President is Gerald E. Hobbs of San Bernardino, California. PLP, has among its membership, miners and prospectors with mining claims and estates in National Forests in California, Federal lands administered by the Bureau of Land Management in California, National Parks in California, and other Federal lands in California, and throughout the United States. Large numbers of the membership of PLP receive yearly permits from DF&G to engage in vacuum or suction dredge mining in California, and do so engage in such mining in California. These PLP members are directly affected in their mining, prospecting and associated operations by passage of SB 670 that prohibits the issuance of permits for vacuum and suction dredge mining by DF&G, and the cancellation by DF&G of permits already issued, for vacuum and suction dredge mining in California. These PLP members are directly and substantially financially harmed by the passage of SB 670.
60. Gerald E. Hobbs is a member of, founder, and President of PLP. Mr. Hobbs has mining claims and mineral estates in three National Forests, all of which are in California. They are Angeles National Forest, Tahoe National Forest, and Six Rivers National Forest. Mr. Hobbs has permits from DF&G to engage in vacuum and suction dredge mining in California. Mr. Hobbs has paid DF&G for these permits. These permits are subject to cancellation, and have been cancelled, by DF&G pursuant to SB 670. Mr. Hobbs has spent substantial sums in order to engage in suction dredge mining. Mr. Hobbs earned income from suction dredge mining in California which was necessary to maintain his economic viability. Mr. Hobbs is directly and substantially financially harmed by the passage of SB 670.
61. Patrick Keene is part of a third generation family-owned business that has been serving the mining community in California, the United States, and throughout the world for the past 60 years. Mr. Keene is Secretary/Treasurer of Keene Engineering Co., Inc. (“Keene Engineering”) of Chatsworth, California. Keene Engineering is the largest supplier of small scale dredging and mining equipment in the world. The Company, as well as many other manufacturers, sells to small businesses and dealers who provide equipment to prospectors and miners throughout California and the United States. Many of the people who operate suction dredges come to visit California to dredge for gold and work their mining claims. While doing so, they support local businesses in the process of filling their other needs. Mr. Keene has been working for Keene Engineering for over 30 years. Mr. Keene is a member of PLP. Mr. Keene and Keene Engineering are directly and substantially financially harmed by the passage of SB 670.
62. The economic impact of the prohibition of suction dredge mining in California is devastating to Keene Engineering. Since the majority of Keene Engineering’s business is in California, it would not allow the Company and the many others small businesses who also sell prospecting and mining equipment or supplies, to survive. Much of Keene Engineering’s business relies on California suction dredge miners. The losses involved with Keene Engineering’s business would be in the many millions of dollars.
63. Since the introduction of SB 670, suction dredge sales by Keene Engineering and its California dealers have stopped. The fear of this activity becoming illegal, and it being a misdemeanor, carrying up to $1,000.00 in fines, and six months in jail, has been devastating to Keene Engineering’s business, as well as its dealers.
64. Forty percent of Keene Engineering’s business is based on equipment sold to small and medium scale suction dredge miners in California, and the people who travel from other states to suction dredge mine in the rivers and streams in California. Thousands of those people also enjoy associated tourism in California and support local seasonal businesses.
65. Most of Keene Engineering’s suppliers, who provided it with components to build suction dredges are profoundly impacted as well. These businesses also have had a substantial drop in their business. The passage of SB 670 has created a ripple effect on many other industries both in and out of the State of California adversely affecting interstate commerce. SB 670’s prohibition on vacuum and suction dredge mining has cost, or will cost, California economic damage in an amount of approximately 60 million dollars a year, and possibly much more.
66. SB 670 will put Keene Engineering out of business. Keene Engineering employs 35 workers. Keene Engineering will lay off approximately 12 employees in an attempt to economically survive. A number of Keene Engineering’s dealers have contacted the Company, and told Keene Engineering that they are closing their doors since they cannot economically survive selling just non-motorized equipment such as sluice boxes and gold pans.
67. The suction dredge community supports many other businesses in gold bearing areas which are in danger of economic failure. Many jobs are being lost due to the loss of tourism that the passage of SB 670 has engendered. Many campgrounds are empty along rivers and mining areas across California. Many businesses are seasonal, including campgrounds, hotels, restaurants, service stations, and grocery stores. Many of these businesses are located in severely economically depressed areas. These business owners rely on small scale suction dredge miners, prospectors, and tourism in order to survive economically. Many of the counties in Northern California, in the gold bearing area, are economically depressed and having very hard economic times. SB 670 is adding to this economic suffering, eliminating jobs, and creating a loss of tax base for these areas and for the State of California.
68. Californians, and people who come from other states to visit California, spend an average of $3,200.00 per month in local economies as of a study made in 1994. In 2009, the amount spent is substantially higher. Californians, and people from other states, purchase special vehicles such as trucks, campers, trailers, quads, and recreational vehicles to prospect and mine for gold in California.
69. Since the passage of SB 670, many mining claim and mineral estates will lose considerable value because their claim owners cannot mine them effectively, and the counties where they are situated will be compelled to reassess the value of their claims. This will create a large loss to County and State tax basis, and will ultimately curtail governmental services.
70. Mr. Keene is also a small scale independent miner who owns mining claims and estates throughout California. Mr. Keene’s mining claims are on Federal land in National Forests in California and on Bureau of Land Management land in California. Mr. Keene engages in vacuum and suction dredge mining in California, and has permits from DF&G allowing him to engage in such mining. Mr. Keene has paid DF&G for these permits. Mr. Keene has spent substantial sums in order to engage in suction dredge mining. Mr. Keene supplements his and his family’s income from being able to engage in suction dredge mining. By not being able to engage in suction dredge mining on Federal land in California, Mr. Keene, in his individual capacity, is directly and substantially financially harmed by the passage of SB 670.
71. Robert Haiduck is a prospector and miner with mining claims and mineral estates in the Sequoia National Forest, Trinity National Forest, Cleveland National Forest, and other National Forests in California. Mr. Haiduck also has mining claims on federal lands administered by the Bureau of Land Management (“BLM”). Mr. Haiduck is a member of PLP. Mr. Haiduck engages in suction dredge mining on his mining claims in the National Forests in California, as well as, his mining claims on lands administered by BLM. No waters where Mr. Haiduck has mining claims contain any salmon of any species whatsoever. Pursuant to BLM regulations, every ten (10) acres of his unpatented mining claims on BLM land must be sampled for mineral values. Since these claims are on the water, they have to be suction dredged to be correctly and legally sampled. Mr. Haiduck has permits from DF&G to engage in suction dredge mining in California. Mr. Haiduck has paid DF&G for these permits. Mr. Haiduck has spent substantial sums in order to engage in suction dredge mining in California. Mr. Haiduck is severely ill. He is financially dependent for the support of himself and his family, which includes three (3) small children, on suction dredge mining on his mining claims in the National Forests and on BLM land in California. Mr. Haiduck and his family have substantial amounts of personal money invested in mining claims that can only be worked feasibly, economically, and in an environmentally friendly manner by suction dredge mining. Without the ability to suction dredge mine Mr. Haiduck and his family stand to lose almost all of their money, and be completely wiped out economically. Being unable to engage in suction dredge mining on his mining claims in the National Forests of California, and BLM land in California, causes immediate and substantial financial harm to Mr. Haiduck and his family. Mr. Haiduck is directly, severely and substantially financially harmed by the passage of SB 670.
72. Terry Stapp is a 60% disabled Vietnam veteran who retired in 1991 after 25 years in the United States Air Force. Mr. Stapp is a suction dredge miner and has so mined on Federal land in the Downieville area in Sierra County, California for over 30 years. His mining claims and estates in Sierra County are worthless without the ability to engage in suction dredge mining. The economic loss to Mr. Stapp and his wife, Dee, is devastating. Mr. Stapp supplemented his income by suction dredge mining while he was on active duty in the United States Air Force. Since Mr. Stapp retired from the Air Force, suction dredge mining in California is his sole source of income, other than his military retirement pension. Mr. Stapp is directly and substantially financially harmed by the passage of SB 670.
73. Dee Stapp is the wife of Terry Stapp. Mrs. Stapp is a member of PLP. Mrs. Stapp has mining claims and estates on Federal land in California. Mrs. Stapp engages in suction dredge mining on her claims in California, and has permits from DF&G to engage in such mining. Mrs. Stapp has paid DF&G for these permits. Mrs. Stapp has spent substantial sums in order to engage in suction dredge mining. Mrs. Stapp supplements her and her husband’s income through suction dredge mining in California. Mrs. Stapp is directly and substantially financially harmed by the passage of SB 670.
74. Mrs. Stapp started a gold prospecting store in San Bernardino, California and has run it since August 1, 1978. Mrs. Stapp sells suction dredges and dredge accessories to miners which represent about 60% of the store’s income. The passage of SB 670 is a devastating economic blow to Mrs. Stapp’s business income. SB 670 has placed in question the economic
viability of Mrs. Stapp’s business, and the ability of her store to remain open.
75. Mrs. Stapp sells the gold she and her husband obtain from suction dredge mining through the Internet throughout the United States and in foreign commerce. The inability to suction dredge mine will substantially impact the Stapps’ financial and economic well-being, since the Internet sales of suction dredge mined gold amounts to many thousands of dollars per year, and is a necessity for the Stapps to financially survive.
76. David DeCosta has been a suction dredge miner in California for over 20 years. Mr. DeCosta is a member of PLP. Mr. DeCosta has mining claims and estates on Federal land in California. Mr. DeCosta has permits from DF&G to engage in suction dredge mining in California. Mr. DeCosta has paid DF&G for these permits. Mr. DeCosta has spent substantial sums in order to engage in suction dredge mining. Suction dredge mining has provided additional income for Mr. DeCosta and his family. Mr. DeCosta and his family are directly and substantially financially harmed by the passage of SB 670.
77. James Gregory Lee has been a suction dredge miner in California for over 40 years. Mr. Lee is partially disabled. Mr. Lee is a member of PLP. Mr. Lee has mining claims and estates on Federal land in California. Mr. Lee has permits from DF&G, including an assistant suction dredge permit for an aide to help him operate his suction dredge, due to his disability, in order to engage in suction dredge mining in California. Mr. Lee has paid DF&G for these permits. Mr. Lee has spent substantial sums in order to engage in suction dredge mining. Suction dredge mining has provided additional income for Mr. Lee and his family. Mr. Lee and his family are directly and substantially financially harmed by the passage of SB 670.
78. Mike Holt has been a suction dredge miner in California for over 24 years. Mr. Holt is a member of PLP. Mr. Holt has mining claims and estates on Federal land in California in the Tahoe National Forest. Mr. Holt has also engaged in suction dredge mining on private properties, for which he needs permits from DF&G. Mr. Holt has permits from DF&G to engage in suction dredge mining in California. Mr. Holt has paid DF&G for these permits. Mr. Holt has spent substantial sums in order to engage in suction dredge mining. Suction dredge mining has provided the main source of income for Mr. Holt and his family. Suction dredge mining has allowed Mr. Holt to support his wife and four children, and in these difficult economic times, to continue to help out his children economically. Mr. Holt and his family are directly and substantially financially harmed by the passage of SB 670.
79. Todd Bracken has been a suction dredge miner in California for over 15 years. Mr. Bracken has been awarded a Certificate of Recognition by the California State Assembly for his mining activities on his family’s historic mining claims, and his use and popularization of California gold throughout the world in his artistic creations. Mr. Bracken is a member of PLP. Mr. Bracken has mining claims and estates on Federal land in California on the Yuba River. Mr. Bracken has permits from DF&G to engage in suction dredge mining in California. Mr. Bracken has paid DF&G for these permits. Mr. Bracken has spent substantial sums in order to engage in suction dredge mining. Suction dredge mining has provided additional income for Mr. Bracken and his family. Mr. Bracken takes much of the gold he obtains from suction dredge mining and uses it to make fine jewelry. Mr. Bracken sells that jewelry throughout the United States and in foreign commerce. This involves many thousands of dollars in sales per year. Mr. Bracken maintains a website advertising his jewelry for sale. That website states that Mr. Bracken sells natural California gold jewelry. California gold commands a higher price in the market place because of its natural purity and the history of gold mining associated with California. The prohibition of suction dredge mining in California dramatically and drastically affects Mr. Bracken’s mining and jewelry business, and its economic viability. Mr. Bracken and his family are directly and substantially financially harmed by the passage of SB 670.
80. Shannon Poe is suction dredge miner in California. Mr. Poe is a member of PLP. Mr. Poe has mining claims and estates on Federal land in California, including National Forest and Bureau of Land Management lands in California. Mr. Poe has permits from DF&G to engage in suction dredge mining in California. Mr. Poe has paid DF&G for these permits. Mr. Poe has spent over $27,000.00 since January 1, 2009 in order to engage in suction dredge mining. Suction dredge mining has provided additional income for Mr. Poe and his family. Mr. Poe and his family are directly and substantially financially harmed by the passage of SB 670.
81. David Richard has been a suction dredge miner in California for over 20 years. Mr. Richard is a member of PLP. Mr. Richard has mining claims and estates on Federal land in California. Mr. Richard has permits from DF&G to engage in suction dredge mining in California. Mr. Richard has paid DF&G for these permits. Mr. Richard has spent substantial sums in order to engage in suction dredge mining. Suction dredge mining has provided additional income for Mr. Richard and his family. Mr. Richard and his family are directly and substantially financially harmed by the passage of SB 670.
82. Defendant State of California is a State of the United States, one of whose agencies is the California Department of Fish and Game (“DF&G”).
83. Defendant Arnold Schwarzenegger is the Governor of the State of California, and is sued in his official capacity as Governor.
84. The California Department of Fish and Game is a department of the Executive Branch of the State of California, and among its other duties, is responsible for the issuing of permits for vacuum and suction dredge mining in the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways within California.
85. Defendant Donald Koch is Director of the California Department of Fish and Game, and is sued in his official capacity as Director of the aforesaid Department.
86. The true names and capacities, whether individual, corporate, associate, or otherwise, of Defendants DOE 1 through DOE 20 are unknown to Plaintiffs at this time, who therefore sue said Defendants by such fictitious names and will ask leave of Court to amend this Complaint to show their true names and capacities when the same are ascertained. Said Defendants are sued as principals and/or agents, servants, and employees of said principals, and all of the acts performed by them as agents, servants, and employees were performed within the course and scope of their authority and employment. Each of the Defendants is in some way responsible for the injuries sustained by the Plaintiffs.
87. At all times herein, all named Defendants and Defendants DOES 1 though 20 inclusive, and each of them, were the agents and employees of each of the remaining Defendants and were at all times acting within the purpose and scope of said agency and employment and each Defendant ratified and approved the acts of its agent.


CLAIMS FOR RELIEF
COUNT I: Preemption and the Supremacy Clauses
88. Plaintiffs repeat and incorporate by reference the allegations of Paragraphs 1 through 87 of this Complaint.
89. The heaviest concentrations of placer gold and other valuable minerals on unpatented mining claims held under Federal law, and on unclaimed Federal lands open to mining, are in waterways where a natural concentration of gold and other valuable minerals is in the gravels and on or near the bedrock of the riverbed or streambed. The only viable, economic and environmentally sound manner to recover the placer gold under these conditions is through use of a suction dredge. Suction dredge mining is the highest and best use for placer mining claims. Miners and prospectors have a federally granted right to use such waters in order to develop their mining claims and mineral estates. 16 U.S.C. § 481 (Use of Waters). All state laws, or regulations, in conflict with this right, are void and of no effect. 43 CFR § 3809.3.
90. Miners and prospectors have a statutory right, not a privilege, to go upon open Federal public domain lands for mineral prospecting, exploration, and development. Administrators may not unreasonably restrict the exercise of that right. The Federal Mining Law of 1872, as amended (30 U.S.C. § 21 et seq.), provides that all valuable mineral deposits in lands belonging to the United States shall be free and open to exploration and development. The Supremacy Clause of the United States Constitution, Article VI, Clause 2, further provides that “the laws of the United States . . . shall be the supreme law of the land . . . with anything in the laws of any state to the contrary notwithstanding”. Article IV, § 3, of the United States Constitution, provides that “Congress shall have the power to dispose of and make all needful rules and regulations respecting the territory or other property belonging to the United States.” The absolute prohibition of SB 670 of vacuum or suction dredge mining in the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways for Federal mining claims within Federal lands in the State of California, directly conflicts with those Federal mining laws, and violates the Supremacy Clause and Article IV, § 3, of the United States Constitution.
91. Plaintiffs are entitled to secure the necessary permits to conduct vacuum or suction dredge mining operations on Federal lands, and the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways within those Federal lands, pursuant to, and including, without limitation, the Mining Acts of 1866 and 1870, the Mining and Minerals Policy Act of 1970, 30 U.S.C. § 21a.; the Federal Mining Law of 1872, as amended (30 U.S.C. § 21 et seq.); 16 U.S.C. § 481, (Use of Waters); the Stock Raising Homestead Act of 1916 (Ch. 9, 39 Stat. 862, codified at 43 U.S.C. § (1976); the Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976 (“FLPMA”) 43 U.S.C. § 1701 et seq., including without limitation §§ 1732(b), 1761 and 1769; the National Forest Management Act (“NFMA”); 16 U.S.C. § 1600 et seq. (1976); Multiple Surface Use Sustained Yield Act (“MUSYA”); 16 U.S.C. § 528 et seq. (1960); Multiple Surface Use Act, 30 U.S.C. §§ 612, 613, 615; Americans with Disabilities Act, 42 U.S.C. § 12132; 5 U.S.C. §§ 601, 602, 603(b), Regulatory Flexibility Act As Amended By The Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act of 1996; 5 U.S.C. §§ 801-808) [SBREFA]; the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. § 4321 et seq.); and numerous sections of the Code of Regulations (“CFR”), including without limitation, 36 CFR 228 et seq.; 36 CFR 261 et seq.; 43 CFR § 3800; 43 CFR § 3809.1 et seq., including without limitation, 43 CFR § 3809.3. Thus, SB 670’s absolute prohibition of vacuum or suction dredge mining in the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways within those Federal lands violates Plaintiffs’ rights pursuant to the aforesaid statutes, rules, and regulations mandated by Congress.
92. SB 670 is prohibitory, not regulatory, in its fundamental character. It strikes at the central purpose and objectives of the applicable Federal law regarding mining. Through SB 670, the State of California attempts to substitute its political judgment for that of Congress. The Federal government has authorized a specific use of Federal lands for mining, and California cannot prohibit that use either temporarily or permanently.
93. Vacuum and suction dredge mining is the only practical way any of the Plaintiffs can economically mine the valuable mineral deposits located in the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways within Federal lands in California. SB 670 is a de facto prohibition on all such mining. To the extent DF&G may issue permits, plaintiffs are entitled to secure the necessary permits to conduct vacuum and suction dredge mining operations on Federal and non-Federal lands within the State of California pursuant to, and including without limitation, the above-stated statutes and regulations. Thus, SB 670’s absolute prohibition of vacuum and suction dredge mining in the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways within Federal and non-Federal lands, violates Plaintiffs’ rights thereto. SB 670 directly conflicts with Federal law relating to mining, and stands as an obstacle to the accomplishment of the full purposes and objectives of Congress in enacting not only the mining laws but all other laws stated above. All matters dealt with by SB 670 are preempted and fully occupied by the laws of the United States, including without limitation, its mining laws, its environmental laws, its laws relating to clean water, 33 U.S.C. § 1151, et seq. (2004), and its laws relating to endangered species, 16 U.S.C. §§ 1531, et seq. (2004).
94. The issuance of a permit for vacuum or suction dredge mining to a mining claim owner, miner and/or prospector by DF&G is a non-discretionary act, and not a discretionary act. The mining laws, as set forth above, give to the miner and/or prospector an absolute and exclusive right to enter and use the Federal public lands, and the rivers, streams, lakes and waterways running therein, for the purpose of mining and developing his or her mineral estate. The Mining Act of 1866 states:
“That the mineral lands of the public domain, both surveyed and unsurveyed, are hereby declared to be free and open to exploration and occupation by all citizens of the United States, and those who have declared their intention to become citizens, subject to such regulations as may be prescribed by law, and subject also to the local custom or rules of miners in the several mining districts, so far as the same may not be in conflict with the laws of the United States.”



COUNT II: Deprivation of Property and Due Process
95. Plaintiffs repeat and incorporate by reference the allegations of Paragraphs 1 through 94 of this Complaint.
96. Prior to the passage of SB 670, plaintiffs invested many thousands of dollars in order to be able to engage in vacuum and suction dredge mining. Plaintiffs obtained Federal mining claims, invested substantial sums in those claims, kept those claims current, paid taxes on those claims, bought and sold equipment, paid permit fees to DF&G, and otherwise spent substantial sums of money for the purpose of conducting mineral exploration and development pursuant to the laws of the United States and the State of California.
97. The due process clauses of the 5th and 14th Amendments to the United States Constitution, and Article I § 7(a) of the Constitution of California, prohibit the deprivation of property without due process of law. The Plaintiffs have constitutionally protected property rights and mineral estates that they own or lease in California. The passage of SB 670 makes such property and mineral estates worthless or near worthless. The State of California, through
and by the passage of SB 670, has wrongfully taken plaintiffs’ property without compensation in violation of the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of California.
98. Defendants, through the passage of SB 670, have deprived the Plaintiffs of their property rights without procedural due process of law in at least the following ways:
a. Failing to give the Plaintiffs notice and an opportunity for a hearing prior to the deprivations; and
b. Failing to provide a mechanism for the Plaintiffs to contest the deprivations of their property rights once they occurred.
99. Defendants, through the passage of SB 670, have deprived the Plaintiffs of substantive due process under the 5th and 14th Amendments of the Constitution of the United States and Article I § 7(a) and Article I §§ 7(a) and 19 of the Constitution of California in at least the following ways:
a. Defendants’ deprivations of Plaintiffs’ property rights are arbitrary and capricious;
b. SB 670 has no rational relationship to any legitimate public purpose; rather it was motivated solely by the improper political purpose of totally prohibiting vacuum or suction dredge mining in the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways of California;
c. SB 670 singles out Plaintiffs for extraordinary treatment different from that accorded to all other potential mineral developers that utilize different methods of mining, or use suction dredge equipment for extensive non-mining purposes. These extensive non-mining purposes have the same effect as suction dredge mining for minerals, and in many cases, far exceed any disturbance to the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways of California, and the biota therein, allegedly caused by suction dredge mining;
d. SB 670 is in direct conflict with the laws of the United States, which state that the mining of minerals on and within Federal lands is necessary for the economic development and security of the United States.
e. SB 670 is in direct conflict with the laws of the State of California, which assert that mining of minerals within the State is necessary for the economic development of the State and Nation;
f. SB 670 contains no standards to apply in that it affects every river, stream, lake, and waterway in California whether or not there are any fish, aquatic life, or biota therein, or any living organism that could possibly be affected in any way whatsoever by vacuum or suction dredge mining; and
g. SB 670 is in direct conflict with the encouragement of mining, including vacuum or suction dredge mining by and in the State of California, as being essential to the economic well-being of California, its people, and the needs of society. Thus, Defendants deprivation of Plaintiffs’ property is manifestly unfair, given that the Plaintiffs, with the State of California’s encouragement, have made a substantial investment for the exploration and development of minerals through suction dredge mining.
///
///

COUNT III: Denial of Equal Protection
100. Plaintiffs repeat and incorporate by reference the allegations of Paragraphs 1 through 99 of this Complaint.
101. The Plaintiffs are entitled to equal protection under the laws of California pursuant to the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States, and Article I § 7(a) of the Constitution of the State of California.
102. Defendants, through the passage of SB 670, specifically intended to deny, and have denied, Plaintiffs the same treatment, privileges, and immunities received by all other mine owners and operators, or potential mine owners or operators, that utilize other than vacuum or suction dredge mining methods, or users of vacuum and suction dredge equipment for purposes other than mining within the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways of California.
103. There is no rational basis for this difference and treatment which has denied Plaintiffs’ equal protection under the laws.


COUNT IV: Taking of Property Without Compensation
104. Plaintiffs repeat and incorporate by reference the allegations of Paragraphs 1 through 103 of this Complaint.
105. Defendants, through the passage of SB 670, have deprived Plaintiffs of their mineral rights and estates within the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways of California in violation of the 5th and 14th Amendments to the Constitution of the United States; and Article I § 7(a) and Article I § 19 of the Constitution of California.
106. SB 670 contains no provision for compensating the Plaintiffs for the substantial property deprivations they have suffered, and will suffer, and the defendants have not compensated, nor offered to compensate, Plaintiffs for such deprivation. Defendants have made clear that they do not intend to offer any such compensation.
107. Plaintiffs are entitled to just compensation for their property taken.
108. The Defendants’ actions in preparing, adopting, and implementing SB 670 and other rules and policies that interfere with, and prohibit, the Plaintiffs’ rights to prospect, and to access their mining claims and mineral estates in the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways of California, were without public purpose, and in direct conflict with the laws of the United States. Such actions have caused and will continue to cause immediate, direct, adverse and irreversible harm to Plaintiffs and other miners and prospectors.


COUNT V: Violation of Civil Rights
109. Plaintiffs repeat and incorporate by reference the allegations of Paragraphs 1 through 108 of this Complaint.
110. Defendants, through the passage of SB 670, have deprived Plaintiffs of their mineral rights, estates, and property within the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways of California, as well as depriving Plaintiffs of rights, privileges, and immunities secured by the Constitution and laws of the United States, as well as the Constitution and laws of the State of California, pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983. Plaintiffs are entitled to attorneys’ and experts’ fees and costs pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1988.
///
///
///

COUNT VI: Violation of the Mining and Minerals Policy Act of 1970,
30 U.S.C. § 21a
111. Plaintiffs repeat and incorporate by reference the allegations of Paragraphs 1 through 110 of this Complaint.
112. The Mining and Minerals Policy Act of 1970, 30 U.S.C. § 21a, declares that it is the continuing policy of the Federal Government to foster and encourage private enterprise in the development of a stable domestic minerals industry and the orderly and economic development of domestic mineral resources. This act includes all minerals, including sand and gravel, geothermal, coals, and oil and gas. 30 U.S.C. § 615 prohibits the interference, limitation, or restriction of any existing rights to any Federal mining claimant holding a valid mining claim on Federal lands.
113. SB 670 hinders the national policy as expressed by Congress to foster and develop mining and mineral resources. The actions of Defendants as set forth above, in closing and prohibiting vacuum and suction dredge mining in the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways within Federal lands in California violates the policy of the Mining and Minerals Policy Act as set forth above.
114. Defendants’ actions were in direct violation of Congressional intent and purpose as set forth above, and an abuse of Plaintiffs’ rights. These actions of Defendants have caused, and will continue to cause, immediate, direct, adverse, and irreversible harm to Plaintiffs, other miners and prospectors, and the United States, as well as the State of California.
///
///
///

COUNT VII: Violation of 30 U.S.C. §§ 21-54 (Mining Act)
115. Plaintiffs repeat and incorporate by reference the allegations of Paragraphs 1 through 114 of this Complaint.
116. 30 U.S.C. § 22 states that: “Except as otherwise provided, all valuable mineral deposits in lands belonging to the United States, both surveyed and unsurveyed, shall be free and open to exploration and purchase, and the lands in which they are found to occupation and purchase, by citizens of the United States and those who have declared their intention to become such, under regulations prescribed by law, and according to the local customs or rules of miners in the several mining districts, so far as the same are applicable and not inconstant with the laws of the United States”. 30 U.S.C. § 615 prohibits the interference, limitation, or restriction of any existing rights of any mining claimant holding a valid mining claim on Federal lands.
117. The lands of the United States cannot be free and open to exploration if the historical means of development and utilization by prospectors and miners can be prohibited by SB 670’s prohibitions and closures, either temporarily or permanently, in an attempt to substitute any other judgment for that of Congress. SB 670 is prohibitive and not merely regulatory.
118. The actions of SB 670 as set forth above in closing and prohibiting vacuum and suction dredge mining to prospecting and developing of mining claims in the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways of California within Federal lands violates the purpose of the aforesaid Act.
119. Defendants’ actions in violating 30 U.S.C. §§ 21-54 (Mining Act) were in direct violation of Congressional intent and purpose as set forth above, and an abuse of Plaintiffs’ rights. These actions have caused and will continue to cause, immediate, direct, adverse, and irreversible harm to Plaintiffs, other miners and prospectors, as well as citizens of the United States who wish to become prospectors and miners.

COUNT VIII: Violation of Plaintiffs’ Implied Rights to Use Public Lands
120. Plaintiffs repeat and incorporate by reference the allegations of Paragraphs 1 through 119 of this Complaint.
121. The mining laws, and other statutes enacted by Congress, granting the right to prospect and mine on the public lands throughout the Western United States, including California, as well as the granting of mining claims and mineral estates to Plaintiffs, and other miners and prospectors, implies a right of access to the minerals therein accompanying the grant, arising out of the rules and customs of prospectors and miners to use such methods as are available for prospecting and mining on Federal lands, and to access their mining claims and mineral estates in an unimpeded manner. Closure by SB 670 to vacuum and suction dredge mining on the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways of California within Federal lands adversely and unlawfully interferes with their implied right, causing them harm and damages.
122. The actions of SB 670, as set forth above, in closing and prohibiting vacuum and suction dredge mining or prospecting and developing of mining claims in the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways of California within Federal lands violates the aforesaid implied right of Plaintiffs. Therefore, Plaintiffs are entitled to an order quieting title to their mining claims and mineral estates, including their right to use vacuum and suction dredge mining in prospecting on Federal lands, and developing their aforesaid mining claims and mineral estates. 28 U.S.C. § 2409 (a).
123. The Defendants’ actions in preparing, adopting and implementing the proposed closure and prohibition, and other rules and policies that interfere with the Plaintiffs’ implied right were in unlawful derogation of Plaintiffs’ rights. Such actions have caused and will continue to cause immediate, direct, adverse and irreversible harm to Plaintiffs, and other miners and prospectors.


COUNT IX: Unlawful Interference with Commerce
124. Plaintiffs repeat and incorporate by reference the allegations of Paragraphs 1 through 123 of this Complaint.
125. Plaintiffs are small business entities that engage in interstate and foreign commerce. The Federal government encourages and favors small business entities. It has established the Small Business Administration to assist such entities, and has passed special laws, rules, and regulations favoring and protecting small business entities. Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. § 603(b) as amended by The Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act Of 1996) 5 U.S.C. §§ 801-808.
126. The Plaintiffs sell or buy valuable minerals obtained through vacuum or suction dredge mining in California on federal lands. Plaintiffs sell such minerals throughout the United States and in foreign commerce. Plaintiffs also use such minerals obtained from federal lands in the manufacture of valuable products that are sold throughout the United States and in foreign commerce.
127. Many citizens of other States and foreign countries come to California in order to engage in vacuum and suction dredge mining for valuable minerals. These non-California citizens purchase permits from DF&G in order to engage in vacuum or suction dredge mining.
128. The total amount of money spent and invested by these mining claim owners, prospectors and miners in suction dredge mining amounts to many millions of dollars each year. The Plaintiffs, and other prospectors and miners, including non-citizens of California, as set forth above, engage in these activities that are specifically authorized, protected, and encouraged by Congress. The Plaintiffs, and other prospectors and miners, including non-citizens of California, engage in interstate and foreign commerce, as set forth above, such interstate and foreign commerce being specifically authorized, protected, and encouraged by Congress.
129. Plaintiffs, and other persons, as set forth above, spend many millions of dollars each year on goods, services, equipment, food, and other supplies both in and out of the State of California in order to engage in suction dredge mining within the State of California.
130. SB 670, by imposing a total prohibition on suction dredge mining in the State of California constitutes an impermissible burden on interstate and foreign commerce in direct
violation of the Constitution of the United States, Article I, § 8, and in direct conflict and in direct violation of the intent and purpose of Congress.
131. Defendants’ actions constituting an undue burden on domestic and foreign commerce are in violation of the Constitution of the United States, Article I, § 8, and are in violation of Congressional intent and purpose as set forth above, and an unlawful derogation and prohibition of Plaintiffs’ rights. These actions have caused, and will continue to cause, immediate, direct, adverse, and irreversible harm to Plaintiffs, non-citizens of California, other miners and prospectors, and citizens of the United States who wish to become prospectors and miners.


COUNT X: Injunctive Relief
132. Plaintiffs repeat and incorporate by reference the allegations of Paragraphs 1 through 131 of this Complaint.
133. Plaintiffs request injunctive relief, since the harm to them from the actions of the Defendants in enacting and implementing SB 670 prohibits them from prospecting and accessing their mining claims and mineral estates in the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways in California within Federal lands. This causes damage to them which is immediate and irreparable, because they must be able to use vacuum and suction dredge methods of mining and prospecting in order to feasibly and economically prospect and mine on their mining claims and mineral estates.
134. The actions of the Defendants as set forth above in closing and prohibiting vacuum and suction dredge mining and prospecting and developing of their mining claims and mineral estates causes Plaintiffs irreparable harm and entitles them to immediate injunctive relief.
135. The Defendants’ actions in preparing, adopting and implementing the closure, prohibition, and other rules and policies that interfere with the Plaintiffs’ rights to prospect, and to access their mining claims and mineral estates as set forth above, are in derogation of Plaintiffs’ rights. Such actions by Defendants have caused, and will continue to cause, immediate, direct, adverse and irreversible harm to Plaintiffs and other miners and prospectors.
136. Plaintiffs are entitled to an immediate injunction, including, without limitation, a temporary restraining order, preliminary injunction, and permanent injunction, enjoining and restraining Defendants from the implementation and enforcement of SB 670, and enjoining and restraining Defendants from interfering with Plaintiffs’ rights to prospect, to access and develop their mining claims and mineral estates, as set forth above, through all lawful means, including, without limitation, motorized mining methods such as vacuum and suction dredging, or by other lawful means.
///

COUNT XI: Damages
137. Plaintiffs repeat and incorporate by reference the allegations of Paragraphs 1 through 136 of this Complaint.
138. As a direct and proximate result of the aforesaid violations by Defendants as set forth in Counts I – X of this Complaint, Plaintiffs have suffered present and future damages in an amount not presently ascertainable, the exact amount to be proven at trial.


DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
PRAYER FOR RELIEF
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs respectfully pray that this Court:
1. Adjudge and declare that the challenged prohibition and closure of the rivers, streams, lakes, and waterways in California is unlawful pursuant to all the acts, laws, and regulations as set forth in Counts I – XI of this Complaint, and that Defendants have acted beyond the scope of their legal authority in adopting those actions, and that such actions violate the Constitution of the United States, and the State of California as set forth above;
2. Enjoin and restrain Defendants, their agents, employees, successors, and all persons acting in concert or participating with them, from enforcing or implementing, and requiring others to enforce or implement, the aforesaid prohibition and closure and related rules, regulations, and polices; and issue a temporary, preliminary and/or permanent injunction against Defendants pursuant to Rule 65, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure;
3. Declare unlawful and set aside SB 670, as being in violation of the Constitution of the United States,and the laws of the United States, as well as the Constitution of the State of California;
4. Issue and order quieting title to Plaintiffs’ mining claims and mineral estates by determining Plaintiffs’ aforesaid property is benefited by an implied right to use vacuum and suction dredge mining in order to prospect on Federal lands and develop Plaintiffs’ mining claims and mineral estates.
5. Grant such damages as are proven at trial, with interest on the damages at the maximum annual rate as allowed by law, from such earliest date as allowed by law;
6. Award the Plaintiffs their reasonable attorneys fees and costs, including expert costs, and expenses of litigation as allowed by law, including, without limitation, and as applicable, the Equal Access to Justice Act, 28 U.S.C. § 241, et seq.; 42 U.S.C. § 1988, California Code of Civil Procedure § 1021.5, the common fund doctrine, and other applicable laws, concepts or doctrines, whether legal or equitable, rules of Court, or other rules and regulations; and
7. Grant such other and further relief as the Court deems just and proper, including an award of attorney’s fees, costs, and expenses.

Dated: September 14, 2009 LAW OFFICES OF DAVID YOUNG
By /s/ David Young David Young
Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Last Updated ( Thursday, 14 January 2010 )
 
< Prev   Next >

Sponsored Links

World Gold Price

[www.kitco.com]